Page:Musical Structure as Narrative in Rock 09.png

This page has been proofread, but needs to be validated.
Encarnacao
Musical Structure as Narrative in Rock

a structure that is truly episodic, yet, musically speaking, does not subscribe to a traditional sense of narrative. A comparison between the structure of this recording and the two already discussed is instructive:

Recording title Sectional structure Analysis
'Welcome to the Working Week' A — B — A — B — C — A — B. Verse (A) — chorus (B) — bridge (C) form. Each verse-chorus unit outlines a quest narrative, and the bridge comprises the furthest point away from the point of origin.
'Everybody’s Gonna Be Happy' (intro on A) — A — B — A — B — A — B — B — A (fade). Strophic form. The strophe consists of verse (A) — chorus (B). Each strophe outlines a quest narrative.
'Drummer Boy' A — B — C — D — C — D — C — E — F (coda) None of these sections is readily identifiable as verse or chorus. Without a return to the point of origin or subscription to the types of sections we expect in rock recordings, there is no sense of quest narrative articulated by the structure.

In the Costello and Kinks tracks, the alternation of sections A and B is integral to their definition as verses and choruses and helps to cement the idea of a place of origin, a move away from that place, and a return. In 'Drummer Boy' we hear four vastly contrasting sections before any of them is repeated, and neither the C nor D section functions as verse or chorus. Additionally, the functional diatonic harmony of the first two examples is not evident in 'Drummer Boy,'[1] and this is underlined by the fact that each section is in a different tempo. These aspects upset any traditional notion of narrative as we have come to expect it to operate in song form.[2]

In terms of sound-mass, while each section works within a standard kit of rock instrumentation — vocals, guitars, drums — the lack of continuity between sections means that the listener is constantly readjusting to different sound-masses which individually carry connotations of the confessional singer-songwriter (A), indie/post-rock (B), hard rock (C), outsider music (D and E) and punk (E). These are not exercises in musical style, it would seem, but rather a through-composed approach to the momentary demands of mood and text. While we might be able to plot a trajectory of intensity

___________________

  1. Sections A, C, D and F all to some extent revolve around the pitch of E, but section B is chromatic and comes to rest on an Eb7 chord, and the riff of section E has a tonal centre of F, so the idea of a tonal centre of E for the track is much disrupted.
  2. This is ironic, as part of the lyric concerns a quest: 'No mortal man has yet succeeded in climbing the big glass mountain. /"I know" said the drummer boy "but my heart is stout and determined / and I long for adventure,"

PORTAL, vol. 8, no. 1, January