252 Southern Historical Society Papers.
the notes of apparently more than double that number of trombones to drown the noise of the moving columns of the enemy concentrating in front of the " Bloody Angle."
Third. I was within a few paces of General Johnson when we were captured ; was with him during the entire time of our imprison- ment ; was exchanged at the same time, and returned with him to Richmond. I, therefore, had abundant opportunity to talk with General Johnson, which we did often, over the disaster of May i2th, and from General Johnson's lips, as well as from my own personal knowledge, I am prepared to confirm General Walker's opinion that neither General Johnson nor his men were surprised at the attack at the time it was made; but, on the contrary, I am quite sure, so far as Jones' brigade was concerned, all of us were expecting it.
I will state two facts, which I think will settle that point: While on duty as "officer of the day," as before stated, on the night of the nth, the enemy became very active, and paraded all the bands and drum corps at their command, making the hills and dales resound with their music from 10 o'clock on the nth till about 4 A. M. of the 1 2th, when all became quiet. At this time Captain W. H. Clary, then on General Johnson's staff, came to me with orders from General Johnson, directing me to see the regiment commanders and tell them to wake up their men and have them in the trenches, and to see that their guns were in good order.
That order was promptly obeyed by Jones' brigade. I suppose that the same orders were given to the other brigades in the division. Of one thing I am sure, however, and that is, that not one of the enemy came over the lines held by the Second (Jones') brigade till after we had surrendered to overwhelming numbers, who had turned our left by crossing our works beyond the salient in question, which threw them immediately on our left and rear.
The left of Jones' brigade rested immediately at the salient, with the entire brigade to the right of it. And just here I hope that Gen- eral Walker will pardon me for saying that he made a slight mistake when he places the salient " not far from the right of Jones' brigade." Then again, General Walker says: " This statement as to the failure of the muskets of our men to fire is true, as to that portion of our line between the Stonewall brigade and the salient, which was, as far as my (his) vision extended; but I have been informed by officers of Jones' brigade that the right of that brigade had been more careful
