Page:Cardozo-Nature-Of-The-Judicial-Process.pdf/38

This page has been proofread, but needs to be validated.
THE METHOD OF PHILOSOPHY

legal problems cannot be reached." [1] We must know where logic and philosophy lead even though we may determine to abandon them for other guides. The times will be many when we can do no better than follow where they point.

Example, if not better than precept, may at least prove to be easier. We may get some sense of the class of questions to which a method is adapted when we have studied the class of questions to which it has been applied. Let me give some haphazard illustrations of conclusions adopted by our law through the development of legal conceptions to logical conclusions. A. agrees to sell a chattel to B. Before title passes, the chattel is destroyed. The loss falls on the seller who has sued at law for the price[2] A. agrees to sell a house and lot. Before title passes, the house is destroyed. The seller sues in equity for specific performance. The loss falls upon the

38
  1. Professor Cook's Introduction.
  2. Higgins v. Murray, 73 N. Y. 252, 254;2 Williston on Contracts, sec. 962;N. Y. Personal Prop. Law, sec. 103a.