Page:Cardozo-Nature-Of-The-Judicial-Process.pdf/56

This page has been proofread, but needs to be validated.
HISTORY, TRADITION AND SOCIOLOGY

conceptions of our law. Metaphysical principles have seldom been their life. If I emphasize the law of real estate, it is merely as a conspicuous example. Other illustrations, even though less conspicuous, abound. "The forms of action we have buried” says Maitland,[1] "but they still rule us from their graves." Holmes has the same thought:[2] "If we consider the law of contract," he says, "we find it full of history. The distinctions between debt, covenant and assumpsit are merely historical, The classification of certain obligations to pay money, imposed by the law irrespective of any bargain as quasi-contracts, is merely historical. The doctrine of consideration is merely historical. The effect given to a seal is to be explained by history alone." The powers and functions of an executor, the distinctions between larceny and embezzlement, the rules of venue and the jurisdiction over foreign trespass, these are a few haphazard illustrations of growths which history has fostered, and which history

56
  1. "Equity and Forms of Action," p. 296.
  2. "The Path of the Law," Io Harvard L. R. 472.