23
| When elected | Members' Names. | Remarks | |
| 1795 | July 1. | George Clusman. | |
| John Nicholas Crentzebach. | |||
| 1796 | Jan. 25 | J. L. Steenback. | |
| Ap'l 25 | Cornelius Hoffman. | ||
| July 25 | Joseph Sterlitz. | ||
| John Miller. | dec'd. | ||
| Edward Dunscomb. | |||
| Oct. 10 | John Remmey. | ||
| Matthias Luft. | |||
| Anthony Rutger. | |||
| Daniel Paris. | |||
| 31 | Daniel Baehr. | ||
| William G. Miller. | |||
| 1797 | Jan. 30 | William Gultzow. | |
| Jan. 30 | George F. Toderhorst. | ||
| Nicholas I. Roosevelt. | |||
| 1798 | Ap'l 30 | Peter Ritter, Junior. | |
| John Hone. | |||
| Jacob Sherred. | |||
| 1799 | Jan. 19 | John Nitchie. | |
| Henry Siebeck. | |||
| 28 | Joseph Horn. | ||
| Lewis Eigenbrodt. | |||
| Charles Loss. | |||
| Joseph Metzler. | |||
| 1800 | Jan. 27 | John I. Werth. | |
| May 12 | Casper Meier. | ||
| Oct. 27 | Edward W. Laight. | ||
| 1802 | 25 | Peter A. Camman. | |
| 1803 | Jan. 25 | Jacob Clinch. | |
| 1804 | Oct. 29 | Clarkson Crolius. | |
| 1805 | Ap'l 29 | George Sassenberg. | |
| July 29 | George Meyer. | ||
| 1806 | Jan. 27 | Anthony Steenback. | |
| John Sidell. | |||
| May 12 | John D. Miller. | ||
| Daniel Fasch. | |||
| 1807 | May 11 | William Klein. | |
| George Minuse. | |||
| John Luff. | |||
