Mr. KING supposes, that, as the pec pie have tacitly agreed to a federal government, therefore the legislature, in every state, have a right to confirm any alterations or amendments in it: a convention in each state to approve of a new government, he supposes, however, the most eligible.
Mr. WILSON is of opinion that the people, by a convention, are the only power that can ratify the proposed system of the new government.
It is possible that not all the states, nay, that not even a majority, will immediately come into the measure; but such as do ratify it will be immediately bound by it, and others as they may from time to time accede to it.
Question put for postponement of this resolve—7 states for postponement, 3 against it.
Question on the 9th resolve, to strike out the words "and of inferior tribunals."
Carried by 5 states against 4; 2 states divided, of which last number New York was one.
Mr. WILSON then moved, "That the national legislature shall have the power to appoint inferior tribunals," be added to the resolve.
Carried by 7 states against 3. New York divided. [N. B. Mr. Lansing, from New York, was prevented by sickness from attending to-day.] Adjourned to to-morrow morning.
Met pursuant to adjournment. Mr. PINCKNEY moved, (pursuant to a standing order for reconsideration,) that, in the 4th resolve, the words "by the people" be expunged, and the words "by the legislatures" be inserted.
Mr. GERRY. If the national legislature are appointed by the state legislatures, demagogues and corrupt members will creep in.
Mr. WILSON is of opinion that the national legislative powers ought to flow immediately from the people, so as to contain all their understanding, and to be an exact transcript of their minds. He observed, that the people had already parted with as much of their power as was necessary to form on its basis a perfect government; and the particular states must part with such a portion of it as to make the present national government adequate to their peace, and the security of their liberties. He admitted that the state govern-
34
