various movements in plants, and it cannot be denied that he
was sometimes led into obscure and doubtful views, as for
instance when without any apparent connection he regarded
the inhalation of oxygen as a mechanical condition of the rising
of the sap and also of heliotropic curvatures, and that his
attempts at explanation were not seldom forced and improbable; but all this does not prevent it from being true, that an
attentive reader will still gain much instruction from his physiological writings and be excited by them to examine for himself.
Dutrochet was a decidedly able man and an independent
thinker, who it is true was often led astray by his prejudices,
but at the same time manfully protested against the old traditional way of dealing with physiological ideas, and substituted
careful examination both of his own and others' investigations
for the accumulation and comfortable retailing of isolated observations which was then the fashion. After de Saussure's
'Recherches chimiques' Dutrochet's 'Memoires pour servir a l'histoire anatomique et physiologique des vegetaux et des animaux,' 1837, are without doubt the best production, which
physiological literature has to show in the long period from
1804 to 1840. If later botanists, instead of dwelling on his
faults, had developed with care and judgment all that was
really good in his general view of vegetable physiology, this
branch of botanical science would not have declined as it did
in the interval between 1840 and 1860. We shall discover
the greatness of Dutrochet as a vegetable physiologist by comparing his work above-mentioned with the best text-books of
the subject of the same time, those of De Candolle, Treviranus, and Meyen; not one of them comes up to Dutrochet's
Memoires in acuteness or depth.
The three text-books just mentioned contained little or nothing new either in facts or ideas on the subject of the nutrition of plants; all three were rather compilations of what was already known, and differed from each other only in their selection of material and in the form which each sought to give
