holdeth fast such a multitude of Stars, which without ever changing site among themselves, are with so much concord carried about, with so great disparity of motions. Or else, supposing the Heavens to be fluid, as we are with more reason to believe, so as that every Star wandereth to and fro in it, by wayes of its own, what rules shall regulate their motions, and to what purpose, so, as that being beheld from the Earth, they appear as if they were made by one onely Sphere? It is my opinion, that they might so much more easily do that, and in a more commodious manner, by being constituted immoveable, than by being made errant, by how much more facile it is to number the quarries in the Pavement of a Piazza, than the rout of boyes which run up and down upon them.The Seventh Confirmation. And lastly, which is the seventh instance, if we attribute the Diurnal Motion to the highest Heaven, it must be constituted of such a force and efficacy, as to carry along with it the innumerable multitude of fixed Stars, Bodies all of vast magnitude, and far bigger than the Earth; and moreover all the Spheres of the Planets; notwithstanding that both these and those of their own nature move the contrary way. And besides all this, it must be granted, that also the Element of Fire, and the greater part of the Air, are likewise forcibly hurried along with the rest, and that the sole little Globe of the Earth pertinaciously stands still, and unmoved against such an impulse; a thing, which in my thinking, is very difficult; nor can I see how the Earth, a pendent body,The Earth a pendent Body, and equilibrated in a fluid Medium seems unable to resist the rapture of the Diurnal Motion. and equilibrated upon its centre, exposed indifferently to either motion or rest, and environed with a liquid ambient, should not yield also as the rest, and be carried about. But we find none of these obstacles in making the Earth to move; a small body, and insensible, compared to the Universe, and therefore unable to offer it any violence.
Sagr.I find my fancy disturbed with certain conjectures so confusedly sprung from your later discourses; that, if I would be enabled to apply my self with atention to what followeth, I must of necessity attempt whether I can better methodize them, and gather thence their true construction, if haply any can be made of them; and peradventure, the proceeding by interrogations may help me the more easily to expresse my self. Therefore I demand first of Simplicius, whether he believeth, that divers motions may naturally agree to one and the same moveable body, or else that it be requisite its natural and proper motion be onely one.
Simpl.To one single moveable,A single moveable hath but onely one natural motion, and all the rest are by participation. there can naturally agree but one sole motion, and no more; the rest all happen accidentally and by participation; like as to him that walketh upon the Deck of a Ship, his proper motion is that of his walk, his motion by participation that which carrieth him to his Port, whither hewould
