Page:North Dakota Reports (vol. 48).pdf/33

This page needs to be proofread.
LOWE v. DISTRICT COURT
9

order different from that which the trial court made, then the matter should be remanded to the district court, as suggested by Mr. Justice Birdzell.

I do not believe, however, that any showing has been made here from which it can reasonably be inferred that the defendant cannot have a fair trial in Ramsey county. It should be noted that the two counties suggested by the plaintiff (McHenry and Renville) as well as (Pierce) the county chosen by the majority members, all lie in the same judicial district as does Ramsey, so apparently plaintiff has no objection to any of the three judges in that district. (And upon the oral argument it was stated that no such objection existed.) So, at the outset it is conceded by all that the trial judge in Ramsey county would be fair and impartial, and afford defendant a fair trial. The crime with which plaintiff is charged has no connection whatever with politics. The plaintiff is not charged with having committed what may be called a "political crime." I do not believe that the people of Ramsey county (or any other county in this state) would desire to see an innocent man accused of rape convicted, or one guilty of that crime acquitted, because he is or is not of a certain political faith. And it is almost unthinkable that because some persons in Ramsey county have been arrested for criminal libel growing out of the recent election campaign, the jurors duly selected and sworn to try a case (from a distant county) wherein the defendant is charged with the crime of rape would violate their oaths as jurors, and permit political bias and prejudice to influence their judgment.

While I disagree with the conclusions reached by the majority members, it is only fair to state that if I deemed it properly a part of my duties to designate a place of trial of the criminal case under consideration, I should have no hesitancy in agreeing that the case might properly be sent to Pierce county. (I am aware of no reason why both parties may not, and will not, receive a fair trial in that county.) Nor am I aware of any reason why a fair trial may not be had in any other county in which the action may conveniently be tried.