Page:North Dakota Reports (vol. 48).pdf/347

This page needs to be proofread.
WEBER v. INTERSTATE BUSINESS MEN’S ACC. ASSO’N
323

It will be noted that the certificate of membership states that the assured—

“is entitled to such benefits as may be provided in and by the articles of incorporation and by-laws of said association in force and effect at the time the accident occurs from which a claim for benefits arises.”

These statements speak for themselves. The certificate of membership by its express terms did not purport to be the whole contract. It specifically referred to the articles of incorporation and the by-laws as establishing the essential elements of the contract. When the contest was raging, during the trial of the cause, as to whether the certificate should be admitted, the trial judge by a mere inspection of the certificate was advised that the benefits conferred upon the assured were those provided in the articles of incorporation and by-laws of the association in effect at the time the accident occurred. This necessarily inferred that whatever limitations there were as to liability were also specified in such articles and by-laws. It was necessary that the certificate of membership be introduced as a foundation for the admission of the articles of incorporation and by-laws. But there is no good reason why the trial court should have believed that the defendant, when it offered the certificate in evidence also, thereby sought to prove the contents of the articles of incorporation and by-laws. Manifestly the articles of incorporation must have been a matter of public record in the state where the association was incorporated; and it is a matter of common knowledge that the by-laws of a corporation are generally entered in some appropriate record of the corporation. Not only is it presumed that the ordinary course of business has been followed, but the very “synopsis” which defendant asserts constitutes evidence of the articles of incorporation and by-laws shows that it is not a copy thereof, but is merely a statement of conclusions as to the contents and effect of the articles and by-laws. It also shows that the articles of incorporation and by-laws are not contained in or in any manner made part of the certificate of insurance, but are extraneous thereto and were set forth in some other document inclosed therewith. It was deemed necessary to conclude the so-called “synopsis” by stating in large type that “the member should read the inclosed copy of the articles of incorporation and of the by-laws carefully and inform himself of the rights and duties of membership” in the association. This was urged upon him as a duty which he owed to himself and to the association. Of course, if the “synopsis” had been a copy or even a complete statement of