Page:North Dakota Reports (vol. 48).pdf/433

This page needs to be proofread.
EDGELEY CO-OP. GRAIN CO v. SPITZER
409

note to the payee. It denies that it was executed or delivered for value received or any legal consideration, and further denies any indebtedness to the plaintiff in any sum whatsoever. In the answer it is further alleged that the sole and only consideration for the execution and delivery of said note by defendant was in substance as follows: That during the months of March and April, 1917, and subsequently thereto, this defendant, acting through the said Pomona Valley Farmers' Elevator Company, as his agent, engaged in the purchase and sale of grain options and in gambling and speculating upon the prices of grain upon various boards of trade, selected by said Pomona Valley Farmers' Elevator Company, and during said periods this defendant, acting through said Pomona Valley Farmers' Elevator Company, as his agent, bought and sold grain options, solely as gambling and speculative operations, it being at all times fully understood by the said Pomona Valley Farmers' Elevator Company, by this defendant, and by all others connected with said transactions, that said transactions were purely and solely gambling and speculative operations; and it was never understood by said Pomona Valley Farmers' Elevator Company, or by this defendant, or by any one else connected therewith, that any actual grain was to be bought or sold, received or delivered by defendant. And defendant alleges that neither this defendant nor Pomona Valley Farmers' Elevator Company, nor any other party connected with the transaction mentioned above, actually intended that there should be any actual transfer, delivery, or receipt of the commodities covered by said options.

The answer is of too great length to be set out in full. The principal defense set forth in the answer is that the entire transaction with reference to the sale and purchase of 10,000 bushels of rye, the facts in reference to which will hereafter be set forth, was one of speculation and gambling. The defendant pleads a counterclaim in the sum of $1,800. the alleged value of the number of bushels of rye delivered by him to the Pomona Valley Farmers' Elevator Company in the fall of 1917, and further claims that it agreed to give credit on the note for that amount which it failed to do. A reply was interposed to the answer averring payment to defendant of the amount of the actual rye delivered in the fall of 1917.

The material facts in the case are substantially as follows: The price of rye in March, 1917, was about $1.49 per bushel. At that time Ernest Steel was the agent of the Pomona Valley Farmers' Elevator Company