Brown Review by Paul Di Filippo

Brown Review by Paul Di Filippo  (2006) 
by Paul Di Filippo

Di Filippo, Paul (August 29, 2006). "Reviews: Classics - What Mad Universe - A sci-fi magazine editor crosses over to an alternate dimension in which every pulp nightmare comes true". Sci Fi Weekly. article, at

BROWN REVIEW by Paul Di Filippo

What Mad Universe

Trapped in a crazy world he never made—or did he?

What Mad Universe By Frederic Brown 1949

Review by Paul Di Filippo

Paul Di Filippo

Sci Fi Weekly

August 29, 2006


Keith Winton has a nice life in the year 1954. He’s editor of a pulp SF zine named Surprising Stories. He’s in love with the beautiful Betty Hadley, a co-worker who edits Perfect Love Stories for the same employer, publisher L. A. Borden. And in fact, this very weekend, Keith and Betty are guests at Borden’s elegant Catskills estate. Too bad Betty has to leave early, to get back to New York. That will certainly mean that she’ll be gone when an experimental moon rocket crashes and explodes on the Borden property, sending Keith Winton through a dimensional rift into a strange and nearly incomprehensible world. A world made all the crazier because of certain deceptive similarities.

Keith awakes on the blank piece of land that does not host the Borden mansion in this continuum. He bums a ride into town, where he finds that one of his familiar quarters is worth thousands of “credits” in an illegal deal. But when he tries to sell a second coin, he’s accused for some reason of being an “Arcturian spy!” He manages to escape local authorities and make his way by train back to New York.

There, he finds the nighttime city locked down in a “mistout,” while deadly gangs of “Nighters” prowl. Barely escaping with his life, he survives till the safety of the dawn, and begins to educate himself in the new universe.

Its history, apparently, deviated from ours in 1903, when a scientist fooling with his wife’s sewing machine invented a spacedrive. Soon the habitable planets of the solar system were colonized. But voyaging beyond our Sun brought mankind into deadly conflict with the Arcturians. Now, all public affairs revolve around the stalemated war, with Earth’s forces led by the polymath genius and warrior, Doppelle, and his mechanical sidekick Mekky.

Desperate to earn a living, Keith conceives of selling remembered and transcribed stories to his editor counterpart, this world’s Keith Winton. But a visit to the offices of Borden Publishing reveals a disturbing sight: Betty, clad in skimpy “space girl” clothing, and engaged to the charismatic Doppelle!

What’s a fifth wheel like the extra Keith Winton to do?

The first recursive SF novel still provides plenty of chuckles today

“Recursive science fiction” is defined as science fiction which takes as its subject matter, at least partially, all the various themes, personages and history of the genre itself. It’s a rarefied subset of the field, but irresistible to fans when well done—and Brown was certainly a clever and facile pioneer. The immense fondness SF fans had for this novel persisted for several generations, although Brown is probably better known today among mystery readers, for his many detective books.

Brown’s first sale in the genre occurred only in 1941, and What Mad Universe was only his first SF novel. But already his appreciation for and knowledge of the field was deep, and his skills exemplary. Nor was he lacking in the ability to keep suspense going. The combination of all these factors resulted in a novel not deep or weighty, nor even acidly satirical, but one that remains a sheer pleasure to read, somewhat like Edmond Hamilton crossed with Thorne Smith.

Brown might have been influenced by Anthony Boucher’s Rocket to the Morgue (1942), a mystery novel that utilized famous SF writers as characters. And perhaps also by L. Ron Hubbard’s 1940 novella, “Typewriter in the Sky.” But Brown’s stroke of genius lay in constructing a deliberately shoddy universe that actually mimicked pulp cliches, but which was absolutely real to its inhabitants. (The explanation of how this universe came into being is the book’s kicker.) There are few funnier scenes in the literature than Keith encountering Betty for the first time in her “space girl” outfit. And yet the book exhibits genuine creepiness in places—the attack of the Nighters, for instance—and a head-spinning sense of deracination.

Surely Philip K. Dick must have had What Mad Universe in mind when he wrote his Eye in the Sky (1957). And like all SF writers, Dick upped the ante, by creating not one shoddy cosmos, but multiple ones.

In writing my novel Fuzzy Dice, I had both Robert Sheckley’s Dimension of Miracles (1968) and this book as models. There’s nothing like stealing from—escuse me, I meant being inspired by—the grandmasters!


This work is released under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported license, which allows free use, distribution, and creation of derivatives, so long as the license is unchanged and clearly noted, and the original author is attributed.


This work is free and may be used by anyone for any purpose. If you wish to use this content, you do not need to request permission as long as you follow any licensing requirements mentioned on this page.

Wikimedia has received an e-mail confirming that the copyright holder has approved publication under the terms mentioned on this page. This correspondence has been reviewed by an OTRS member and stored in our permission archive. The correspondence is available to trusted volunteers here.