History of Woman Suffrage/Volume 6/Chapter 45
CHAPTER XLV.
VIRGINIA.[1]
The earliest record of woman suffrage in Virginia bears the name of Mrs. Hannah Lee Corbin of Gloucester county, whose protest in 1778 against taxation without representation was answered by a letter from her brother, Richard Henry Lee ("Lighthorse Harry'), who wrote that in his opinion under the clause in the constitution which gave the vote to householders she could exercise the suffrage.
There had been a suffrage organization in Virginia in 1893, of which Mrs. Orra Langhorne, a pioneer worker, had been president. When the State Equal Suffrage League was organized, Miss Laura Clay of Kentucky gave to it a trust fund of $2.50 which had been left in the treasury and Mrs. Langhorne had requested her to give to a Virginia League when one should be formed. In November, 1909, a preliminary meeting was held to discuss organization, followed a week later by the forming of the Equal Suffrage League of Virginia. Lila Meade (Mrs. B. B.) Valentine, widely known for her public work, was elected president and served in this capacity for the next eleven years. State and city headquarters were opened in Richmond and remained there. Miss Mary Johnston was greatly interested and used her influence in promoting the new organization. Miss Ellen Glasgow also was very active. The league was organized to work for suffrage by both State and Federal action and early in its existence circulated a petition to Congress for a Federal Amendment. In 1910 this was presented to the Virginia members by Mrs. Valentine and the State delegates attending the national suffrage convention.
In January, 1911, the first public meeting ever held in 666 HISTORY OF WOMAN SUFFRAGE mond in the interest of woman suffrage was addressed by Dr. Anna Howard Shaw, president of the National American Woman Suffrage Association, with Dr. Lyon G. Tyler, president of William and Mary College, in the chair. The first State conven- tion was held this year in Richmond with delegates present from Norfolk, Lynchburg, Williamsburg and Highland Springs so- cieties, and individual suffragists from Fredericksburg and Char- lottesville. In 1912 the convention was held in Norfolk with delegates from twenty-two leagues. In 1913 it met in Lynch- burg and the reports showed that 2,500 new members had been added and Mrs. Valentine had made 100 public speeches. An outdoor demonstration was held in Richmond on the steps of the State Capitol, May 2, 1914, in conformity with the nation- wide request of the National Association, and the celebration was continued in the evening. The convention was held in Roa- noke, where it was reported that forty-five counties had been organized in political units and that the Virginia Suffrage News, a monthly paper, was being published at State headquarters under the management of Mrs. Alice Overbey Taylor. In 1915 street meetings were inaugurated and held in Rich- mond from May till Thanksgiving, and in Norfolk, Newport News, Portsmouth, Lynchburg and Warrenton. For the first time women appeared on the same platform with the candidates for the Legislature and presented the claims of the women of Virginia to become a part of the electorate. The May Day celebration was held on the south portico of the Capitol on the afternoon of May I, after a morning devoted to selling from street booths copies of the Woman's Journal, suffrage flags, but- tons and postcards. A band played and the decorations and ban- ners in yellow and blue, the suffrage and Virginia colors, made a beautiful picture. John S. Munce of Richmond introduced the speakers, Dr. E. N. Calisch, Rabbi of Beth Ahaba Temple; Miss Joy Montgomery Higgins of Nebraska and Miss Mabel Vernon of Washington, D. C. In December the convention was held in Richmond and the two hundred delegates marched to the office of the Governor, Henry Carter Stuart, to request him to embody in his message to the General Assembly a recom- mendation that it submit to the voters an equal suffrage amendVIRGINIA 667 ment to the State constitution. They were led by Mrs. Valentine and brief addresses were made by Mrs. Stephen Put- ney of Wytheville, Mrs. Lloyd Byars of Bristol, Mrs. John H. Lewis of Lynchburg, Miss Lucy Randolph Mason of Rich- mond, great-great-granddaughter of George Mason, author of the Virginia Bill of Rights; Miss Agnes Randolph, great-great- granddaughter of Thomas Jefferson, founder of the University of Virginia; Miss Mary Johnston, Mrs. Sally Nelson Robins of Richmond, author; Miss Elizabeth Cooke of Norfolk, Miss Ja- netta FitzHugh of Fredericksburg, Mrs. Kate Langley Bosher of Richmond, author; Miss Roberta Wellford of University; Mrs. George Barksdale, Miss Marianne Meade and Miss Adele Clark of Richmond. He received them courteously but not seri- ously and paid no attention to their request. During the year organization of the State into legislative and congressional dis- tricts was begun. Norfolk was the place of the annual conven- tion in 1916 when in leagues were reported. This was a legis- lative year and all efforts were concentrated on the Assembly. 1 From January 29 to February 2, 1917, a very successful suf- frage school was conducted in Richmond under the auspices of the National Association. Later when the services of this asso- ciation were offered to the Government for war work the league dedicated itself to State and country and endeavored to carry out the plans of the National Board. The president, Mrs. Valen- tine, was the first person in the State, on request of the Gov- ernor, to speak in the recruiting campaign and other members took part in it. At the annual convention held in Richmond in oember a resolution not only again endorsing the Federal Suffrage Amendment but pledging members to work for it unanimously adopted. Virginia sent the largest delegation in her history to the national convention in Washington in De
- mber and it was upon the advice of the returning delegates
it emphasis was laid upon enrollment of those who desired 1 From year to year delegate* from the Equal Suffrage League went to the State political convention!, taking for an endorsement of woman suffrage. The Republicans, the minority party, always received them courteously and a few times put the plank in thrir platform. The Democrats always treated them with discourtcny and never endorsed woman suffrage in any way until 1920. whrn they "commended the action of the General Assembly in passing the Qualifications Bill contingent upon the ratification and proclamation of the igth Amendment." 668 HISTORY OF WOMAN SUFFRAGE woman suffrage. Because of the influenza epidemic no State convention was held in 1918. The enrollment of 32,000 men and women was accomplished in 1919, Mrs. Faith W. Morgan, a vice-president of the associa- tion, securing the largest number of names and Miss Ellen Rob- inson being the first person to fill her quota. The submission by Congress of the Federal Suffrage Amendment in June of this year gave great impetus to the work. In November the annual convention was held in Richmond, with representatives from all parts of the State. At this time there were 175 suffrage centers. The members reaffirmed with enthusiasm their determination to carry on the fight for ratification. An important feature of the year had been the endorsement of the amendment by the State Teachers' Association, the State Federation of Women's Clubs and the Women's Benevolent Association of the Maccabees. 1 On Sept. 9, 10, 1920, the State league met in convention in the hall of the House of Delegates in the Capitol for the joint purpose of celebrating the proclamation of the Federal Suffrage Amendment and planning for the organization of a League of Women Voters. It was an occasion never to be forgotten, with a welcome extended by Governor Westmoreland Davis, speeches by Attorney General John R. Saunders, State Superintendent of Public Instruction Harris Hart and members of the Legislature who had made the fight for ratification. Mrs. Maud Wood Park, president of the National League of Women Voters, gave an inspiring address and extensive plans for future work were made. A reception was given by the wife of the Governor assisted by the officers of the league. On November 10, in the Senate cham- ber, the State League of Women Voters was organized with Mrs. Valentine honorary chairman; Mrs. John H. Lewis honorary vice-chairman and Miss Adele Clark chairman. 1 There were very few changes in officers during the eleven years of the league's existence. The list was as follows: Honorary vice-presidents, Miss Mary Johnston. Miss Ellen Glasgow. Vice-presidents: Mrs. Kate Waller Barrett, Mrs. Louise Collier Willcox, Mrs. C. V. Meredith, Mrs. T. Todd Dabney, Mrs. W. J. Adams. Mrs. John H. Lewis, Miss Nannie Davis, Mrs. Stephen Putney, Mrs. Kate Langley Bosher, J. Allen Watts, Mrs. W. T. Yancey, Mrs. C. E. Townsend, Mrs. W. W. King. Mrs. J. H. Whitner, Mrs Faith W. Morgan, Mrs. Robert Barton; secretaries, Mrs. Ali Tyler, Miss Adele Clark, Mrs. Grace H. Smithdeal, Miss Roberta Wellford, Miss Lucinda Lee Terry; treasurers: Mrs. C. P. Cadot, Mrs. E. G. Kidd; auditors: Mrs. John S. Munce, Mrs. Henry Aylett Sampson, Mrs. S. M. Block. VIRGINIA 669 LEGISLATIVE ACTION. For improved conditions for women in industry, child labor laws and all welfare legislation before the General Assembly in the past ten years individual members of the league have labored assiduously. The league as an organiza- tion, however, has confined itself to work for suffrage, knowing that the vote gained "all things else would be added." 1900. When the constitutional convention met to draft the present State constitution, Mrs. Carrie Chapman Catt, president of the National American Woman Suffrage Association, and a small group of Virginia and other southern women appeared before it and Mrs. Catt urged it to embody woman suffrage in the new constitution but this was not done. 1912. The first resolution proposing an amendment to the State constitution enfranchising women was introduced in the House by Hill Montague of Richmond and the hearing granted by the committee created statewide interest. The speakers were Mrs. Valentine, Mrs. Lewis, Miss Johnston, Mrs. Bosher, Miss Randolph, Clayton Torrence and Howard T. Colvin of the State Federation of Labor, later Assistant U. S. Commissioner of Labor. The vote in the House was 12 ayes, 84 noes. 1914. The resolution for a State amendment was again in- troduced in the House and a hearing granted by the Committee on Privileges and Elections. Mrs. Valentine presided and intro- duced the following speakers : Mrs. Desha Breckinridge of Ken- tucky ; Mrs. Kate Waller Barrett of Alexandria, State regent of the D. A. R. ; Mrs. Putney, Mrs. Lewis, Mrs. Barksdale of Richmond, Miss Mason, Miss Lillie Barbour, State factory in- spector, and Mr. Colvin. The vote was 13 ayes, 74 noes. 1916. The resolution for a State amendment had its first public hearing before a joint committee of the Houste and Senate. The speakers were Mrs. Valentine, Mrs. J. H. Whitner of Roa- noke, a vice-president of the State League ; Miss Eudora Ramsey and Miss Adele Clark of Richmond; the Rev. John J. Wicker, r of Leigh Street Baptist Church, Richmond, and E. F. Sheffey of Lynchburg. The I louse vote, 40 ayes, 51 noes, marked the third defeat but an ii,< D suffrage sentiment. [8. The Legislative Committee consisted of Mrs. Valen- tine, Miss Wellford, Mr k L. Jobson, Miss Clark, Miss 670 HISTORY OF WOMAN SUFFRAGE Nora Houston and Mrs. Munce, all of Richmond. The Federal Suffrage Amendment having now passed the Lower House of Congress, a resolution urging the U. S. Senate to take favorable action on the Federal Amendment was introduced but it did not come out of committee. The Hon. William Jennings Bryan stopped over trains to pay his respects to Governor West- moreland Davis. He was escorted to the Capitol by members of the Equal Suffrage League and made a brief address to the Assembly in joint recess, urging ratification of the Federal Amendment if submitted in time for action at this session. 1 RATIFICATION. The Legislature assembled August 13, 1919, in special session for the purpose of meeting the federal appro- priation for good roads. The Federal Suffrage Amendment hav- ing been submitted to the Legislatures for ratification on June 4 was due to be presented by the Governor. As the special session had been called specifically for good roads, the State Equal Suffrage League intended to await the regular session of 1920 to press for action but to test the legislators a questionnaire was sent to them. Answers proved that it would be well-nigh impossible to obtain ratification at this time, even though sub- stantial petitions from all sections of the State were shown to men representing the localities from which these came. Spurred on, however, by efforts of the National Woman's Party to secure action at any cost, the opponents succeeded in having a Rejection Resolution railroaded through the House without debate ten minutes before adjournment in the second week of the session. The Senate refused to sanction such tactics and by 19 to 15 voted to postpone action until the next session. 1920. The State league's committee on ratification was com- posed of Mrs. Valentine, Miss Clark, Mrs. Bosher, Mrs. Jobson, Miss Houston and Miss Mary Elizabeth Pidgeon. 2 Miss Jose- phine Miller, an organizer for the National Association, was sent into the State toward the end of the campaign. There were 1 By act of the General Assembly of 1918 women were admitted to William and Mary College. They were admitted to the graduate and professional schools of the University of Virginia by act of the Board of Visitors in 1920. 'Miss Pidgeon was appointed by the National Association in November, 1919, for organization to prepare for ratification of the Federal Suffrage Amendment. After its defeat the next February she continued until June 15, organizing citizenship schools throughout the State. The expense to the association was $1,792. VIRGINIA 671 in the two Houses 61 new members who had been elected since the Federal Amendment was submitted. Very strong pressure to ratify was made upon the General Assembly. President Wil- son sent an earnest appeal and others came from Homer Cum- mings, chairman of the National Democratic Committee; A. Mitchell Palmer, U. S. Attorney General; Carter Glass, U. S. Treasurer; U. S. Representative C. C. Carlin and other promi- nent Democrats. Thousands of telegrams were sent from women throughout the southern States. A cablegram came from Lady Astor, M. P. of Great Britain, a Virginian. Urgent requests for ratification were made by presidents of colleges, mayors of cities, State and county officials and other eminent citizens. Before the Governor had even sent the certified copy of the amendment to the Legislature its strongest opponent, Senator Leedy, also an opponent of the administration at Washington, introduced a Rejection Resolution couched in the same obnoxious terms he had used in August. By urgent advice of the leaders he finally omitted some of its most offensive adjectives. It was presented in the House by Representative Ozlin and referred to the Federal Relations Committee, which granted a hearing. On the preceding evening Mrs. Carrie Chapman Catt, president of the National Suffrage Association, addressed a mass meeting held by the Equal Suffrage League in the Jefferson Hotel. The hearing was held before a joint session of the Senate and House in the Hall of Delegates at noon on January 21. Some of Vir- ginia's foremost citizens spoke for ratification, among them Allan Jones, member of the State Democratic Committee; Ros- well Page, State auditor and a brother of the Hon. Thomas on Page; U. S. Representatives Thomas Lomax Hunter and Howard Cecil (lilmer; J. B. Saul, chairman of the Roanoke County Democratic Committee; former Senator Keezel; Dr. Lyon G. Tyler. The women >ieakers were Mrs. ('alt, Mrs. Valentine, president, and Mrs. John II. Lewis, vice- president of the State Suffrage League, and Mrs. Kale Waller r.arrett. 1 1 The next day. after Mr. Catt had returned to New York, Harry St. George - appeared before the Legislature and her and her speech in the most insulting terras. In 1921 Mr. Tucker was a candidate for Governor ;in<l was <1< at the primaries by Senator K. Lee Trinklc, whose plurality was 40,000. He had been a strong supporter of woman suffrage and his victory was attributed to the women. 672 HISTORY OF WOMAN SUFFRAGE Notwithstanding this very able presentation the Federal Rela- tions Committee reported the Rejection Resolution favorably. On the floor Lindsay Gordon of Louisa county substituted a Ratification Resolution and Harry Rew of Accomac a substitute to refer ratification to the voters. The latter carried on January 27 by a vote of 55 to 39, supported by Representatives Gordon, Willis of Roanoke, Williams of Fairfax, Hunter of Stafford, Rodgers, J. W. Story, Wilcox of Richmond, Snead of Chester- field and H. W. Anderson, Republican floor leader. The battle front now shifted to the Senate, where, owing to illness of the chief suffrage proponent, G. Walter Mapp, con- sideration had been postponed. On February 6, the day finally set, proceedings were similar to those in the House, Senator E. Lee Trinkle's ratification resolution and Senator Gravatt's referendum being respectively substituted for Leedy's rejection. The referendum, under Leedy's coercive method, was voted down. All day the contest raged on the ratification resolution, with strong speeches in favor by Senators Trinkle of Wythe, Corbitt of Portsmouth, Paul of Rockingham, Layman of Craig, West of Nansemond, Parsons of Grayson. Supporting the measure by vote were also Senators Crockett, Haslinger and Profitt ; and pairing in favor Pendleton and Gravatt. The Ratifying Resolu- tion was defeated. The Rejection Resolution was adopted by 24 to 10 votes; in the House by 16 to 22. One week later the resolution of Senator J. E. West to submit to the voters a woman suffrage amendment to the State constitu- tion passed the Senate by 28 ayes, n noes; the House by 67 ayes, 10 noes; as it would have to pass the Legislature of 1921 and ratification of the Federal Amendment was almost completed, this vote was merely an empty compliment. A few days there- after the Qualifications Bill, offered by Senator Mapp, was over- whelmingly adopted, Senate, 30 ayes, 6 noes; House, 64 ayes, 17 noes. It made full provisions for the voting of women if the Federal Amendment should be ratified.
- ↑ The History is indebted for this chapter to Mrs. Edith Clark Cowles, Executive and Press Secretary: Mise Adele Clark, Legislative Chairman, and Min Ida Mae Thompson, Headquarters Secretary of the State Equal Suffrage League.