Letters concerning the English Nation/Letter XV

by Voltaire

---

---

LETTER XV.

ON

ATTRACTION.

THE Discoveries which gain'd Sir Isaac Newton so universal a Reputation, relate to the System of the World, to Light, to Geometrical Infinities; and lastly to Chronology, with which he us'd to amuse himself after the Fatigue of his severer Studies.

I will now acquaint you (without Prolixity if possible) with the few Things I have been able to comprehend of all these sublime Ideas. With Regard to the System of our World, Disputes were a long Time maintain'd, on the Cause that turns the Planets, and keeps them in their Orbits; and on those Causes which make all Bodies here below descend towards the Surface of the Earth.

The System of Des Cartes explain'd and improv'd since his Time, seem'd to give a plausible Reason for all those Phænomena; and this Reason seem'd more just, as 'tis simple, and intelligible to all Capacities. But in Philosophy, a Student ought to doubt of the Things he fancies he understands too easily, as much as of those he does not understand.

Gravity, the falling of accelerated Bodies on the Earth, the Revolution of the Planets in their Orbits, their Rotations round their Axis, all this is mere Motion. Now Motion can't perhaps be conceiv'd any otherwise than by Impulsion; therefore all those Bodies must be impelled. But by what are they impelled? All Space is full, it therefore is fill'd with a very subtile Matter, since this is imperceptible to us; this Matter goes from West to East, since all the Planets are carried from West to East. Thus from Hypothesis to Hypothesis, from one Appearance to another, Philosophers have imagin'd a vast Whirlpool of subtile Matter, in which the Planets are carried round the Sun: They also have created another particular Vortex which floats in the great one, and which turns daily round the Planets. When all this is done, 'tis pretended that Gravity depends on this diurnal Motion; for, say these, the Velocity of the subtile Matter that turns round our little Vortex, must be seventeen Times more rapid than that of the Earth; or, an case its Velocity is seventeen Times greater than that of the Earth, its centrifugal Force must be vastly greater, and consequently impell all Bodies towards the Earth. This is the Cause of Gravity, according to the Cartesian System. But the Theorist, before he calculated the centrifugal Force and Velocity of the subtile Matter, should first first have been certain that it existed.

Sir Isaac Newton seems to have destroy'd all these great and little Vortices, both that which carries the Planets round the Sun, as well as the other which supposes every Planet to turn on its own Axis.

First, with regard to the pretended little Vortex of the Earth, 'tis demonstrated that it must lose its Motion by insensible Degrees; 'tis demonsrated, that if the Earth swims in a Fluid, its Density must be equal to that of the Earth; and in case its Density be the same, all the Bodies we endeavour to move must meet with an insuperable Resistance.

With regard to the great Vortices, they are still more chimerical, and 'tis impossible to make them agree with Kepler's Law, the Truth of which has been demonstrated. Sir Isaac shows, that the Revolution of the Fluid in which Jupiter is suppos'd to be carried, is not the same with regard to the Revolution of the Fluid of the Earth, as the Revolution of Jupiter with respect to that of the Earth. He proves, that as the Planets make their Revolutions in Elipsis's, and consequently being at a much greater Distance one from the other in their Aphelia, and a little nearer in their Perihelia; the Earth's Velocity, for Instance, ought to be greater, when 'tis nearer Venus and Mars, because the Fluid that carries it along, being then more press'd, ought to have a greater Motion; and yet 'tis even then that the Earth's Motion is slower.

He proves that there is no such Thing as a celestial Matter which, goes from West to East, since the Comets traverse those Spaces, sometimes from East to West, and at other Times from North to South.

In fine, the better to resolve, if possible, every Difficulty, he proves, and even by Experiments, that 'tis impossible there should be a Plenum; and brings back the Vacuum, which Aristotle and Des Cartes had banish'd from the World.

Having by these and several other Arguments destroy'd the Cartesian Vortices, he despair'd of ever being able to discover, whether there is a secret Principle in Nature which, at the same Time, is the Cause of the Motion of all celestial Bodies, and that of Gravity on the Earth. But being retir'd in 1666, upon Account of the Plague, to a Solitude near Cambridge; as he was walking one Day in his Garden, and saw some Fruits fall from a Tree, he fell into a profound Meditation on that Gravity, the Cause of which had so long been sought, but in vain, by all the Philosophers, whilst the Vulgar think there is nothing mysterious in it. He said to himself, that from what height soever, in our Hemisphere, those Bodies might descend, their Fall wou'd certainly be in the Progression discover'd by Galileo; and the Spaces they run thro' would be as the Square of the Times. Why may not this Power which causes heavy Bodies to descend, and is the same without any sensible Diminution at the remotest Distance from the Center of the Earth, or on the Summits of the highest Mountains; Why, said Sir Isaac, may not this Power extend as high as the Moon? And in Case, its Influence reaches so far, is it not very probable that this Power retains it in its Orbit, and determines its Motion? But in case the Moon obeys this Principle (whatever it be) may we not conclude very naturally, that the rest of the Planets are equally subject to it? In case this Power exists (which besides is prov'd) it must increase in an inverse Ratio of the Squares of the Distances. All therefore that remains is, to examine how far a heavy Body, which should fall upon the Earth from a moderate height, would go; and how far in the same Time, a Body which should fall from the Orbit of the Moon, would descend. To find this, nothing is wanted but the Measure of the Earth, and the Distance of the Moon from it.

Thus Sir Isaac Newton reason'd. But at that Time the English had but a very imperfect Measure of our Globe, and depended on the uncertain Supposition of Mariners, who computed a Degree to contain but sixty English Miles, whereas it consists in reality of near seventy. As this false Computation did not agree with the Conclusions which Sir Isaac intended to draw from them, he laid aside this Pursuit. A half-learn'd Philosopher, remarkable only for his Vanity, would have made the Measure of the Earth agree, any how, with his System: Sir Isaac, however, chose rather to quit the Researches he was then engag'd in. But after Mr. Picart had measur'd the Earth exactly, by tracing that Meridian, which redounds so much to the Honour of the French, Sir Isaac Newton resum'd his former Reflexions, and found his Account in Mr. Picart's Calculation.

A Circumstance which has always appear'd wonderful to me, is, that such sublime Discoveries should have been made by the sole Assistance of a Quadrant and a little Arithmetic.

The Circumference of the Earth is one hundred twenty three Millions, two hundred forty nine thousand six hundred Feet. This, among other Things, is necessary to prove the System of Attraction.

The instant we know the Earth's Circumference, and the Distance of the Moon, we know that of the Moon's Orbit, and the Diameter of this Orbit. The Moon performs its Revolution in that Orbit in twenty seven Days, seven Hours, forty three Minutes. 'Tis demonstrated, that the Moon in its mean Motion, makes an hundred and fourscore and seven thoufand, nine hundred and sixty Feet (of Paris) in a Minute. 'Tis likewise demonstrated, by a known Theorem, that the central Force which should make a Body fall from the height of the Moon, would make its Velocity no more than fifteen Paris Feet in a Minute of Time. Now, if the Law by which Bodies gravitate, and attract one another in an inverse Ratio of the Squares of the Distances be true; if the same Power acts; according to that Law, throughout all Nature; 'tis evident that as the Earth is sixty Semi-diameters distant from the Moon, a heavy Body must necessarily fall (on the Earth) fifteen Feet in the first Second, and fifty four thousand Feet in the first Minute.

Now a heavy Body falls, in reality, fifteen Feet in the first Second, and goes in the first Minute fifty four thousand Foot, which Number is the Square of sixty multiplied by fifteen. Bodies therefore gravitate in an inverse Ratio of the Squares of the Distances; consequently, what causes Gravity on Earth, and keeps the Moon in its Orbit, is one and the same Power; it being demonstrated that the Moon gravitates on the Earth, which is the Center of its particular Motion, 'tis demonstrated that the Earth and the Moon gravitate on the Sun which is the Center of their annual Motion.

The rest of the Planets must be subject, to this general Law; and if this Law exists, these Planets must follow the Laws which Kepler discover'd. All these Laws, all these Relations are indeed observ'd by the Planets with the utmost Exactness; therefore the Power of Attraction causes all the Planets to gravitate towards the Sun, in like Manner as the Moon gravitates towards our Globe.

Finally, as in all Bodies, Re-action is equal to Action, 'tis certain that the Earth gravitates also towards the Moon; and that the Sun gravitates towards both: That every one of the Satellites of Saturn gravitates towards the other four, and the other four towards it: All five towards Saturn, and Saturn towards all. That 'tis the same with regard to Jupiter; and that all these Globes are attracted by the Sun, which is reciprocally attracted by them.

This Power of Gravitation acts proportinably to the Quantity of Matter in Bodies, a Truth which Sir Isaac has demonstrated by Experiments. This new Discovery has been of use to show, that the Sun (the Center of the planetary System) attracts them all in a direct Ratio of their Quantity of Matter combin'd with their nearness. From hence Sir Isaac, rising by Degrees to Discoveries which seem'd not to be form'd for the human Mind, is bold enough to compute the Quantity of Matter contain'd in the Sun and in every Planet; and in this Manner shows, from the simple Laws of Mechanicks, that every celestial Globe ought necessarily to be where it is plac'd.

His bare Principle of the Laws of Gravitation, accounts for all the apparent Inequalities in the Course of the celestial Globes. The Variations of the Moon are a necessary Consequence of those Laws. Moreover, the Reason is evidently seen why the Nodes of the Moon perform their Revolutions in nineteen Years, and those of the Earth in about twenty six Thousand. The several Appearances observ'd in the Tides, are also a very simple Effect of this Attraction. The Proximity of the Moon when at the full, and when it is new, and its Distance in the Quadratures or Quarters combin'd with the Action of the Sun, exhibit a sensible Reason why the Ocean swells and sinks.

After having shown, by his sublime Theory, the Course and Inequalities of the Planets, he subjects Comets to the same Law. The Orbit of these Fires (unknown for so great a Series of Years,) which was the Terror of Mankind, and the Rock against which Philosophy split; plac'd by Aristotle below the Moon, and sent back by Des Cartes above the Sphere of Saturn, is at last plac'd in its proper Seat by Sir Isaac Newton.

He proves that Comets are solid Bodies which move in the Sphere of the Sun's Activity; and that they describe an Ellipsis so very eccentric, and so near to Parabola's, that certain Comets must take up above five hundred Years in their Revolution.

The learned Dr. Halley is of opinion, that the Comet seen in 1680, is the same which appear'd in Julius Cæsar's Time. This shows more than any other, that Comets are hard, opake Bodies; for it descended so near to the Sun, as to come within a sixth Part of the Diameter of this Planet from It; and consequently might have contracted a Degree of Heat two thousand Times stronger than that of red hot Iron; and would have been soon dispers'd in Vapour, had it not been a firm, dense Body. The guessing the Course of Comets began then to be very much in vogue: The celebrated Bernoulli concluded by his System, that the famous Comet of 1680, would appear again the 17^th of May 1719. Not a single Aftronomer in Europe went to Bed that Night; however they needed not to have broke their Rest, for the famous Comet never appear'd. There is at least more Cunning, if not more Certainty, in fixing its Return to so remote a Distance as five hundred and seventy five Years. As to Mr. Whiston, he affirm'd very seriously, that in the Time of the Deluge a Comet overflow'd the terrestrial Globe; and he was so unreasonable as to wonder that People laugh'd at him for making such an Assertion. The Ancients were almost in the same way of Thinking with Mr. Whiston, and fancied that Comets were always the Fore-runners of some great Calamity which was to befall Mankind. Sir Isaac Newton, on the contrary, suspected that they are very beneficent; and that Vapours exhale from them merely to nourish and vivify the Planets, which imbibe in their Course the several Particles the Sun has detach'd from the Comets; an Opinion which at least is more probable than the former. But this is not all. If this Power of Gravitation or Attraction acts on all the celestial Globes, it acts undoubtedly on the several Parts of these Globes. For in case Bodies attrast one another in Proportion to the Quantity of Matter contain'd in them, it can only be in Proportion to the Quantity of their Parts; and if this Power is found in the whole, 'tis undoubtedly in the half, in the quarter, in the eighth Part, and so on in infinitum.

This is Attraction, the great Spring by which all Nature is mov'd. Sir Isaac Newton after having demonstrated the Existence of this Principle, plainly forsaw that its very Name wou'd offend; and therefore this Philosopher in more Places than one of his Books, gives the Reader some Caution about it. He bids him beware of confounding this Name with what the Ancients call'd occult Qualities; but to be satisfied with knowing that there is in all Bodies a central Force which acts to the utmost Limits of the Universe, according to the invariable Laws of Mechanicks.

'Tis surprising, after the solemn Protestations Sir Isaac made, that such eminent Men as Mr. Sorin and Mr. de Fontenelle, should have imputed to this great Philosopher the verbal and chimerical Way of Reasoning of the Aristotelians; Mr. Sorin in the Memoirs of the Academy of 1709, and Mr. de Fontenelle in the very Elogium of Sir Isaac Newton.

Most of the French, the Learned and others, have repeated this Reproach. These are for ever crying out, why did he not imploy the Word Impulsion, which is so well understood, rather than that of Attraction, which is unintelligible.

Sir Isaac might have answer'd these Criticks thus: First, you have as imperfect an Idea of the Word Impulsion, as of that of Attraction; and in case you cannot conceive how one Body tends towards the Center of another Body, neither can you conceive by what Power one Body can impell another.

Secondly, I cou'd not admit of Impulfion, for to do this, I must have known that a celestial Matter was the Agent; but so far from knowing that there is any such Matter, I have prov'd it to be merely imaginary.

Thirdly, I use the Word Attraction for no other Reason, but to express an Effect which I discover'd in Nature; a certain and indisputable Effect of an unknown Principle; a Quality inherent in Matter, the Cause of which Persons of greater Abilities than I can pretend to, may, if they can, find out.

What have you then taught us? Will these People say further: And to what Purpose are so many Calculations to tell us what you yourself don't comprehend?

I have taught you, may Sir Isaac rejoin, that all Bodies gravitate towards one another in proportion to their Quantity of Matter; that these central Forces alone, keep the Planets and Comets in their Orbits, and cause them to move in the Proportion before set down. I demonstrate to you, that 'tis impossible there should be any other Cause which keeps the Planets in their Orbits, than that general Phenomenon of Gravity, or heavy Bodies fall on the Earth according to the Proportion demonstrated of central Forces; and the Planets finishing their Course according to these same Proportions, in case there were another Power that acted upon all those Bodies, it would either increase their Velocity, or change their Direction. Now not one of those Bodies ever has a single Degree of Motion or Velocity, or has any Direction but what is demonstrated to be the Effect of the central Forces; consequently 'tis impossible there should be any other Principle.

Give me Leave once more to introduce Sir Isaac speaking: Shall he not be allow'd to say, My Case and that of the Ancients is very different. These saw, for Instance, Water ascend in Pumps, and said, the Water rises because it abhors a Vacuum. But with regard to my self, I am in the Case of a Man who should have first observ'd that Water ascends in Pumps, but should leave others to explain the Cause of this Effect. The Anatomist who first declar'd, that the Motion of the Arm is owing to the Contraction of the Muscles, taught Mankind an indisputable Truth; but are they lese oblig'd to him because he did not know the Reason why the Muscles contract? The Cause of the Elasticity of the Air is unknown, but he who first discover'd this Spring perform'd a very signal Service to natural Philosophy. The Spring that I discover'd was more hidden and more universal, and for that very Reason Mankind ought to thank me the more. I have discover'd a new Property of Matter, one of the Secrets of the Creator; and have calculated and discover'd the Effects of it. After this shall People quarrel with me about the Name I give it.

Vortices may be call'd an occult Quality because their Existence was never prov'd: Attraction on the contrary is a real Thing, because its Effects are demonstrated, and the Proportions of it are calculated. The Cause of this Cause is among the Arcana of the Almighty.

Procedes huc, & non amplius.
Hither thou shalt go, and no farther.