Page:A History of Architecture in All Countries Vol 2.djvu/78

62 POINTED STYLE IN GERMANY. Pakt II. the ribs few and weak, the ridge undulating, the surfaces twisted, and the general effect poor and feeble as compared with the gorgeous walls that support it. Very judicious painting might remedy tliis to some extent ; but as it now stands the effect is most vin])leasing. The noblest as well as the most original part of the design of this cathedral is the western fapade (Woodcut No. 512). Had this been completed, it would have risen to the height of 510 ft. This front, considered as an independent feature, without reference to its position, is a very grand conception. It equals in magnificence those designed for Strasburg and Louvain, and surpasses both in purity and elegance, though it is very questionable if the open work of the spires is not carried to far too great an extent, and even the lower part designed far too much by rule. M. Boisseree says, "the square and the triangle here reign supreme ; " and this is certainly the case : every part is designed with the scale and the compasses, and Avitli a mathematical precision perfectly astonishing; but we miss all the fanciful beauty of the more irregular French and English exam])les. The storied porches of Rheims, Cliartres, and Wells comprise far more poetry within their limited dimensions than is spi'ead over the whole surface of this gigantic frontispiece. Cologne is a noble concei)tion of a mason, but these were the works of artists in tlie- higliest sense of the word. It is certainly to be regretted that there is no contemporary French example to compare with Cologne, so that we might have been enabled to bring this to a clearer test than words can do. St. Ouen's comes nearest to it in age and style, but it is so very much smaller as hardly to admit of comparison ; for though the length of the two churches is nearly identical, the one covers 91,000 square feet, the other little more than half that, or only 47,000. Yet so judicious is the disposition of the smaller church, and so exquisite its proportions, that notwithstanding the late age of its nave, and the ina])pro]>riateness of its modern front, it is internally a more beautiful and almost as imposing a church as that of Cologne, and externally a far more jileasing study as a work of art. Had Marc d'Argent commenced his building at the same time as the builder of Cologne, and seen it completed, or had he left his design for it prior to 1332, even Avith its smaller dimensions, it would have been by far the nobler work of art of the two. These, however, are after all but vain speculations. We see in Cologne the finest specimen of masonry attempted in the Middle Ages ; and notwithstanding its defects, we may hope to see in the completed design a really beautiful and noble building, worthy of its builders and of the religion to which it is dedicated. Fortunately we are not left solely to the drawings of the fa9ade of Cologne to enable us to judge of Avhat the effect of these open-work spires would be if completed ; for at Friburg, in the Brisgau, there is