Page:Carroll - Euclid and His Modern Rivals.djvu/138

This page has been proofread, but needs to be validated.
100
WILSON.
[Act II.

Nie. That would be true, no doubt.

Min. But this extension of limit will require several modifications in Euclid's language: for instance, what is your Definition of an obtuse angle?


Niemand reads.

P. 8. Def. 13. 'An obtuse angle is one which is greater than a right angle.'

Min. So you tumble headlong into the very first pitfall you come across! Why, that includes such angles as 180° and 360°. You would teach your pupil, I suppose, that one portion of a straight Line makes an obtuse angle with the other, and that every straight Line has an obtuse angle at each end of it!

Nie. It is an oversight—of course we ought to have added 'but less than two right angles.'

Min. A very palpable oversight. I fear we shall find more as we go on. What Axioms have you about angles?


Niemand reads.

P. 5. Ax. 4. 'An angle may be conceived as transferred to any other position, its magnitude being unaltered.'

Min. Hardly worth stating. Proceed.


Niemand reads.

P. 5. Ax. 5. 'Angles are equal when they could be placed on one another so that their vertices would coincide in position, and their arms in direction.'

Min. 'Placed on one another'! Did you ever see the child's game, where a pile of four hands is made on the