Page:Carroll - Euclid and His Modern Rivals.djvu/196

This page has been proofread, but needs to be validated.

ACT III.

Scene I.

§ 1. The other Modern Rivals.

'But mice, and rats, and such small deer,
Have been Tom's food for seven long year.'


Min. I consider the question, as to whether Euclid's system and numeration should be abandoned or retained, to be now set at rest: the subject of Parallels being disposed of, no minor points of difference can possibly justify the abandonment of our old friend in favour of any Modern Rival. Still it will be worth while to examine the other writers, whose works you have brought with you, as they may furnish some valuable suggestions for the improvement of Euclid's Manual.

Nie. The other writers are Chauvenet, Loomis, Morell, Reynolds, and Wright.

Min. There are a few matters, as to which we may consider them all at once. How do they define a straight Line?

Nie. All but Mr. Reynolds define it as the shortest distance between two points, or more accurately, to use the