Judge ELLSWORTH. I move that the words "out of the national treasury " be stricken out, and the words "the respective state legislatures " be inserted.
If you ask of the states what is reasonable, they will comply; but if you ask of them more than is necessary to form a good government, they will grant you nothing.
Capt. DAYTON. The members should be paid from the general treasury, to make them independent.
The question was put on the amendment, and lost—5 ayes, 6 noes.
Mr. MASON. 1 make no motion, but throw out, for the consideration of the Convention, whether a person in the second branch ought not to be qualified as to property.
The question was then put on the clause, and lost—5 ayes, 6 noes.
It was moved to strike out the clause "to be ineligible to any state office."
Mr. MADISON. Congress heretofore depended on state interests; we are now going to pursue the same plan.
Mr. WILSON. Congress has been ill managed, because particular states controlled the Union. In this Convention, if a proposal is made promising independency to the general government, before we have done with it, it is so modified and changed as to amount to nothing. In the present case, the states may say, Although I appoint you for six years, yet if you are against the state, your table will be unprovided. Is this the way you are to erect an independent government?
Mr. BUTLER. This second branch I consider as the aristocratic part of our government; and they must be controlled by the states, or they will be too independent.
Mr. PINCKNEY. The states and general government must stand together. On this plan have I acted throughout the whole of this business. I am therefore for expunging the clause. Suppose a member of this house was qualified to be a state judge; must the state be prevented from making the appointment?
Question put for striking out—8 ayes, 3 noes.
The 5th resolve, that each house have the right of originating bills, was taken into consideration, and agreed to.
Adjourned till to-morrow morning.
Met pursuant to adjournment. Present, eleven states.
