Open main menu
This page has been proofread, but needs to be validated.
870
[GASES
CONDUCTION, ELECTRIC
Ions in Gases sucked from Flames.
Velocities varying from .04 to .23 McClelland
Ions in Flames containing Salts.
Negative ions 12.9 cm./sec. Gold
+ions for salts of Li, Na, K, Rb, Cs 62 H. A. Wilson
200 Marx
80 Moreau
Ions liberated by Chemical Action.
Velocities of the order of 0.0005 cm./sec. Bloch


Ions from Point Discharge.
Hydrogen 5.4 7.43 6.41 Chattock
Carbonic acid 0.83 0.925 0.88 Chattock
Air 1.32 1.80 1.55 Chattock
Oxygen 1.30 1.85 1.57 Chattock

It will be seen from this table that the greater mobility of the negative ions is very much more marked in the case of the lighter and simpler gases than in that of the heavier and more complicated ones; with the vapours of organic substances there seems but little difference between the mobilities of the positive and negative ions, indeed in one or two cases the positive one seems slightly but very slightly the more mobile of the two. In the case of the simple gases the difference is much greater when the gases are dry than when they are moist. It has been shown by direct experiment that the velocities are directly proportional to the electric force.

Variation of Velocities with Pressure.—Until the pressure gets low the velocities of the ions, negative as well as positive, vary inversely as the pressure. Langevin (loc. cit.) was the first to show that at very low pressures the velocity of the negative ions increases more rapidly as the pressure is diminished than this law indicates. If the nature of the ion did not change with the pressure, the kinetic theory of gases indicates that the velocity would vary inversely as the pressure, so that Langevin’s results indicate a change in the nature of the negative ion when the pressure is diminished below a certain value. Langevin’s results are given in the following table, where p represents the pressure measured in centimetres of mercury, V+ and V− the velocities of the positive and negative ions in air under unit electrostatic force, i.e. 300 volts per centimetre:—

Negative Ions. Positive Ions.
p. V−. pV−/76. p. V+. pV+/76.
7.5 6560 647 7.5 4430 437
20.0 2204 580 20.0 1634 430
41.5 994 530 41.5 782 427
76.0 510 510 76.0 480 420
142.0 270 505 142.0 225 425

The increase in the case of pV− indicates that the structure of the negative ion gets simpler as the pressure is reduced. Wallisch in some experiments made at the Cavendish Laboratory found that the diminution in the value of pV− at low pressures is much more marked in some gases than in others, and in some gases he failed to detect it; but it must be remembered that it is difficult to get measurements at pressures of only a few millimetres, as the amount of ionization is so exceedingly small at such pressures that the quantities to be observed are hardly large enough to admit of accurate measurements by the methods available at higher pressures.

Effect of Temperature on the Velocity of the Ions.—Phillips (Proc. Roy. Soc., 1906, 78, p. 167) investigated, using Langevin’s method, the velocities of the + and − ions through air at atmospheric pressure at temperatures ranging from that of boiling liquid air to 411° C.; R1 and R2 are the velocities of the + and − ions respectively when the force is a volt per centimetre.

R1. R2. Temperature Absolute.
2.00 2.495 411°
1.95 2.40 399°
1.85 2.30 383°
1.81 2.21 373°
1.67 2.125 348°
1.60 2.00 333°
1.39 1.785 285°
0.945 1.23 209°
0.235 0.235  94°

We see that except in the case of the lowest temperature, that of liquid air, where there is a great drop in the velocity, the velocities of the ions are proportional to the absolute temperature. On the hypothesis of an ion of constant size we should, from the kinetic theory of gases, expect the velocity to be proportional to the square root of the absolute temperature, if the charge on the ion did not affect the number of collisions between the ion and the molecules of the gas through which it is moving. If the collisions were brought about by the electrical attraction between the ions and the molecules, the velocity would be proportional to the absolute temperature. H. A. Wilson (Phil. Trans. 192, p. 499), in his experiments on the conduction of flames and hot gases into which salts had been put, found that the velocity of the positive ions in flames at a temperature of 2000° C. containing the salts of the alkali metals was 62 cm./sec. under an electric force of one volt per centimetre, while the velocity of the positive ions in a stream of hot air at 1000° C. containing the same salts was only 7 cm./sec. under the same force. The great effect of temperature is also shown in some experiments of McClelland (Phil. Mag. [5], 46, p. 29) on the velocities of the ions in gases drawn from Bunsen flames and arcs; he found that these depended upon the distance the gas had travelled from the flame. Thus, the velocity of the ions at a distance of 5.5 cm. from the Bunsen flame when the temperature was 230° C. was .23 cm./sec. for a volt per centimetre; at a distance of 10 cm. from the flame when the temperature was 160° C. the velocity was .21 cm./sec; while at a distance of 14.5 cm. from the flame when the temperature was 105° C. the velocity was only .04 cm./sec. If the temperature of the gas at this distance from the flame was raised by external means, the velocity of the ions increased.

We can derive some information as to the constitution of the ions by calculating the velocity with which a molecule of the gas would move in the electric field if it carried the same charge as the ion. From the theory of the diffusion of gases, as developed by Maxwell, we know that if the particles of a gas A are surrounded by a gas B, then, if the partial pressure of A is small, the velocity u with which its particles will move when acted upon by a force Xe is given by the equation

u = Xe D,
(p1/N1)

where D represents the coefficient of inter-diffusion of A into B, and N1 the number of particles of A per cubic centimetre when the pressure due to A is p1. Let us calculate by this equation the velocity with which a molecule of hydrogen would move through hydrogen if it carried the charge carried by an ion, which we shall prove shortly to be equal to the charge carried by an atom of hydrogen in the electrolysis of solutions. Since p1/N1 is independent of the pressure, it is equal to Π/N, where Π is the atmospheric pressure and N the number of molecules in a cubic centimetre of gas at atmospheric pressure. Now Ne = 1.22×1010, if e is measured in electrostatic units; Π = 106 and D in this case is the coefficient of diffusion of hydrogen into itself, and is equal to 1.7. Substituting these values we find

u = 1.97×104X.

If the potential gradient is 1 volt per centimetre, X = 1/300. Substituting this value for X, we find u = 66 cm./sec, for the velocity of a hydrogen molecule. We have seen that the velocity of the ion in hydrogen is only about 5 cm./sec, so that the ion moves more slowly than it would if it were a single molecule. One way of explaining this is to suppose that the ion is bigger than the molecule, and is in fact an aggregation of molecules, the charged ion acting as a nucleus around which molecules collect like dust round a charged body. This view is supported by the effect produced by moisture in diminishing the velocity of the negative ion, for, as C. T. R. Wilson (Phil. Trans. 193, p. 289) has shown, moisture tends to collect round the ions, and condenses more easily on the negative than on the positive ion. In connexion with the velocities of ions in the gases drawn from flames, we find other instances which suggest that condensation takes place round the ions. An increase in the size of the system is not, however, the only way by which the velocity might fall below that calculated for the hydrogen molecule, for we must remember that the hydrogen molecule, whose coefficient of diffusion is 1.7, is not charged, while the ion is. The forces exerted by the ion on the other molecules of hydrogen are not the same as those which would be exerted by a molecule of hydrogen, and as the coefficient of diffusion depends on the forces between the molecules, the coefficient of diffusion of a charged molecule into hydrogen might be very different from that of an uncharged one.

Wellisch (loc. cit.) has shown that the effect of the charge on the ion is sufficient in many cases to explain the small velocity of the ions, even if there were no aggregation.

Mixture of Gases.—The ionization of a mixture of gases raises some very interesting questions. If we ionize a mixture of two very different gases, say hydrogen and carbonic acid, and investigate the nature of the ions by measuring their velocities, the question arises, shall we find two kinds of positive and two kinds of negative ions moving with different velocities, as we should do if some of the positive ions were positively charged hydrogen molecules, while others were positively charged molecules of carbonic acid; or shall we find only one velocity for the positive ions and one for the negative? Many experiments have been made on the velocity of ions in mixtures of two gases, but as yet no evidence has been found of the existence of two different kinds of either positive or negative ions in such mixtures, although some of the methods for determining the velocities of the ions, especially Langevin’s, ought to give

evidence of this effect, if it existed. The experiments seem to show