Page:English Historical Review Volume 35.djvu/332

This page has been proofread, but needs to be validated.
324
THE MASTERS OF THE SCHOOLS AT
July

manuscript includes not only letters relating to Arnold's disputes with his bishop, Ivo, but also a number of domestic letters which could not have been of interest outside his immediate circle. As the names are mostly given only in initials, it is not possible to identify them all with absolute certainty; but enough is plain to enable us to fix the date of the collection. Bishop Ivo died on 23 December[1] 1115, and few of the letters are later than that year. It is necessary to state positively that Ivo died in 1115, because the year has been given differently by recent writers. M. Léon Mirot places it in 1116,[2] and Father De Ghellinck in 1117.[3] Both dates are wrong; for Paschal II announced the consecration of Ivo's successor, Geoffrey, in a letter of which the original is still preserved at Chartres, dated from the Lateran on 5 April.[4] This can have been written only in 1116; for in April 1117 the pope was not at Rome but at Benevento, and in January 1118 he died.

One letter (viii) is so early as 1087, but most belong to the first fifteen years of the twelfth century. Among them is a group of familiar letters addressed to their mother Letitia by two schoolboys A. and James (ix–xi). Letitia I take to be the sister of Dean Arnold; she is afterwards mentioned as a widow (xxxiv). The editor of the letters would carry the letters back to an earlier generation and make Letitia the dean's mother.[5] But the two brothers were boys together, and they are associated in a letter (xvi) addressed to Geoffrey, dean of Le Mans, when the younger, James, was still a student. Now Geoffrey was dean in 1096, possibly a little earlier, and was made archbishop of Rouen in 1111. Arnold, however, was already dean of Chartres in 1087, and it is not likely that he had a brother of student's age ten years or more later.[6] That they were Dean Arnold's nephews is a conjecture which I base on the fact that letters of this sort appear in a collection mainly connected with him and his family. Arnold had also a nephew Hugh, who in time became dean himself. A letter which bears no name (xiv) sends messages to the writer's father and uncle (avunculus), his mother and grandmother, which perhaps bring together the dean and his sister. From

    his successor Sampson appears on 29 November 1119 (ibid. viii. 1199 b). The charter of Bishop Geoffrey, which makes Arnold still dean in 1120 in the third year of his episcopate (ibid. instr. 320), contains incompatible dates.

  1. Cartulaire de Notre-Dame de Chartres, ed. E. de Lépinois and L. Merlet, iii. 225, 1865.
  2. Chronique de Morigny, p. 15, n. 2, 2nd ed., 1912.
  3. Le Mouvement théologique du douzième Siècle, p. 297, 1914.
  4. Cartul. de Notre-Dame de Chartres, i. 123, 1862; Jaffé, Reg. 6518, 2nd ed.
  5. Bibl. de l'École des Chartes, 4th ser. i. 469 n. So, too, A. Clerval, Les Écoles de Chartres au Moyen-Âge, pp. 194, 217, 1895.
  6. Merlet, p. 459, strangely attributes this letter (xvi) to Dean Arnold, at the time when he had resigned the deanery. But this was after 1114, and then Geoffrey was archbishop.