Page:Freud - Leonardo da Vinci, a psychosexual study of an infantile reminiscence.djvu/102

This page has been validated.
88
LEONARDO DA VINCI

resentation differs widely from all that is otherwise known. Muther states:[1]

“Some masters like Hans Fries, the older Holbein, and Girolamo dei Libri, made Anne sit near Mary and placed the child between the two. Others like Jakob Cornelicz in his Berlin pictures, represented Saint Anne as holding in her arm the small figure of Mary upon which sits the still smaller figure of the Christ child.” In Leonardo's picture Mary sits on her mother's lap, bent forward and is stretching out both arms after the boy who plays with a little lamb, and must have slightly maltreated it. The grandmother has one of her unconcealed arms propped on her hip and looks down on both with a blissful smile. The grouping is certainly not quite unconstrained. But the smile which is playing on the lips of both women, although unmistakably the same as in the picture of Monna Lisa, has lost its sinister and mysterious character; it expresses a calm blissfulness.[2]

  1. l. c. p. 309.
  2. A. Konstantiriowa, l. c, says: “Mary looks tenderly down on her beloved child with a smile that recalls the mysterious expression of la Gioconda.” Elsewhere speaking of