Page:Hofstede de Groot catalogue raisonné, Volume 3, 1910.djvu/151

IX FRANS HALS '37 A COMPARATIVE TABLE ENABLING THE READER TO IDENTIFY IN THIS CATALOGUE THE PICTURES ENUMERATED BY BODE AND MOES Dr. W. Bode's Studien zur Geschichte der hollandischen Malerei contains a list of Hals' pictures, referred to as " B " ; and E. W. Moes gives another list in his Frans Hals, sa vie et son tzuvre, Brussels, 1909, referred to as " M." The number in the first column of a picture described by Bode or by Moes corresponds in this catalogue to the number given in the second or third column respectively. Thus, if the reader desires to find B. 13, he must look for 13 in the first column and then notice the corresponding number in the second column headed " B.," namely, 139. Thus B. i3 = HdG. 139. B. M. B. M. B. M. I 431 431 22 35 6 162 43 189 I8 7 2 432 432 23 414 I6 3 44 190 I 9 I 3 433 433 24 208 I6 5 45 9 8 190 4 434 434 25 209 1 66 46 I 9 7 188 5 435 428 26 171 195* 47 249 189 6 436 435 27 137 1 68 48 135 193 7 437 436 28 357 169 49 417 194 8 438 437 2 9 125 170 5 37 164 9 154 438 3 3i3 171 5 1 114 197 10 155 149 31 188 173 52 69 199 ii o 150 32 i93 175 53 54 200 12 153 151 33 136 176 54 ( 3 ) 201 '3 139 152 34 64 180 55 157 2O2 14 138 153 35 44 181 56 158 2O3 15 427 154 36 43 183 57 202 204 16 ( 2 ) 155 37 49 H7 58 203 208 17 63 o 38 304 148 59 218 209 18 212 156 39 379 185 60 375 2IO '9 428 '59 40 ' 173 306 61 137 211 20 152 1 60 4i 119 = M. 163 62 ( 4 ) 212 21 234 161 42 389 186 63 117 213 1 Portrait Group of the Beresteyn Family. Since this picture was taken down from its high place on the wall of the Grande Galerie in the Louvre and rehung in one of the new cabinets where it can be studied in detail, its attribution to Frans Hals has been generally doubted. Critics are not agreed as to its probable painter. H. G. Pot's name is perhaps received with most favour. 2 The Roguish Fool, Rijksmuseum ; it is a copy of 98 (B. 45). 8 Zither-Player, Beurnonville sale, Paris, 1881, No. 306; a copy after the picture by Judith Leyster, formerly in the Six collection, now in the Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam. 4 The Roguish Fool, painted about 1635, formerly in the collection of Count Mniszech, Pans ; it is a copy.