however to be taken from the people, if they are their own
worst enemies. The hypothesis which rejects the idea of a
moral gravitation, and asserts that parts of the same entity
naturally repel each other, is thought by our policy to be
unphilosophical. Hence it infers, that it would be as wise
and prudent to entrust national liberty to the exclusive care
of three guardians, all composed of political power, as a bag
of money to three thieves. According to Mr. Adanis's system, three thieves can never carry off the bag of money,
because they can never agree about its division. Parts of
power and of knavery, attract each other and coalesce like
drops of water: drops, however, may be kept asunder, but
rivers will soon form a sea.
To excuse this striking defect in the system of orders, Mr. Adams produces their virtual responsibility. This acknowledges the defect. The question therefore is, whether the remedy is sufficient. Virtual responsibility (as it was termed by the British parliament) can only be enforced by civil war; whilst actual responsibility may be enforced without it. Their difference is demonstrated in the cases of Lewis XVI, and the second President of the United States: and the preference, in relation both to the nation and the magistrate, is obvious.
Against the oppressions of Mr. Adams's hereditary representatives, nations have no remedy but physical strength; against those of temporary representatives, the moral force of opinion suflices. The first remedy can never be legally exerted, because no government will make laws to punish itself; to avoid which, these hereditary representatives invariably disarm the people, and so make the remedy for the coertion of this virtual representation quite nominal. Its use is morcover prohibited by the dreadful avenger of rebellion. Restrained by the dangers which beset it, the physical strength of a nation moves only in the paroxysm inspired by long suffering or extreme peril; and it is to the overthrow of reason, by this paroxysm, that the frequent disappointments of national exertion, to enforce virtual responsibility, are to be ascribed.
