Page:Joseph Story, Commentaries on the Constitution of the United States (1st ed, 1833, vol I).djvu/452

This page has been proofread, but needs to be validated.
412
CONSTITUTION OF THE U. STATES.
[BOOK III.

ter be held the true interpretation. This rule results from the dictates of mere common sense; for every instrument ought to be so construed, ut magis valeat, quam pereat.[1] For instance, the constitution confers on congress the power to declare war. Now the word declare has several senses. It may mean to proclaim, or publish. But no person would imagine, that this was the whole sense, in which the word is used in this connexion. It should be interpreted in the sense, in which the phrase is used among nations, when applied to such a subject matter. A power to declare war is a power to make, and carry on war. It is not a mere power to make known an existing thing, but to give life and effect to the thing itself.[2] The true doctrine has been expressed by the Supreme Court: "If from the imperfection of human language there should be any serious doubts respecting the extent of any given power, the objects, for which it was given, especially when those objects are expressed in the instrument itself, should have great influence in the construction."[3]

§ 429. IX. Where a power is remedial in its nature, there is much reason to contend, that it ought to be construed liberally. That was the doctrine of Mr. Chief Justice Jay, in Chisholm v. Georgia;[4] and it is generally adopted in the interpretation of laws.[5] But this liberality of exposition is clearly inadmissible, if it extends beyond the just and ordinary sense of the terms.

§ 430. X. In the interpretation of a power, all the ordinary and appropriate means to execute it are to be
  1. See Bacon's Abridg. Statute I; Vattel, B. 2, ch. 17, § 277 to 285, 299 to 302.
  2. See Bets v. Tingey, 4 Dall. R. 37; S. C. 1 Peters's Cond. R. 221.
  3. Gibbons v. Ogden, 9 Wheat. R. 1, 188, 189.
  4. 2 Dall. R. 119; S. C. 2 Cond. R. 635, 652.
  5. Bacon's Abridg. Statute I. 8.