Page:Joseph Story, Commentaries on the Constitution of the United States (1st ed, 1833, vol II).djvu/103

This page has been proofread, but needs to be validated.
CH. IX.]
HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES.
95

Statute of 14 Geo. 3, ch. 58.[1] This circumstance is not a little remarkable in parliamentary history; and it establishes, in a very striking manner, how little mere theory can be regarded in matters of government. It was found by experience, that boroughs and cities were often better represented by men of eminence, and known patriotism, who were strangers to them, than by those chosen from their own vicinage. And to this very hour some of the proudest names in English history, as patriots and statesmen, have been the representatives of obscure, and, if one may so say, of ignoble boroughs.

§ 619. An attempt was made in the convention to introduce a qualification of one year's residence before the election; but it failed, four states voting in favour of it, six against it, and one being divided.[2] The omission to provide, that a subsequent non-residence shall be a vacation of the seat, may in some measure defeat the policy of the original limitation. For it has happened, in more than one instance, that a member, after his election, has removed to another state, and thus ceased to have that intimate intercourse with, and dependence upon his constituents, upon which so much value has been placed in all his discussions on this subject.

§ 620. It is observable, that no qualification, in point of estate, has been required on the part of members of the house of representatives.[3] Yet such a qualification is insisted on, by a considerable number of the states, as a qualification for the popular branch of the
  1. 1 Black. Comm. 175; 2 Wilson's Law Lect. 142.
  2. Journal of Convention, 8 August, p. 224, 225.
  3. Journal of Convention, 26 July, p. 204, 205; id. 212; id. 241, 242.