Page:Joseph Story, Commentaries on the Constitution of the United States (1st ed, 1833, vol III).djvu/581

This page has been proofread, but needs to be validated.
CH. XXXVIII.]
JUDICIARY—COMPENSATION.
573

preference to the other.[1] But it is clear, from the language of the constitution, that, in one form or the other, it is absolutely obligatory upon congress, to vest all the jurisdiction in the national courts, in that class of cases at least, where it has declared, that it shall extend to "all cases."[2]

§ 1697. In the next place, the jurisdiction, which is by the constitution to be exercised by the Supreme Court in an original form, is very limited, and extends only to cases affecting ambassadors, and other public ministers, and consuls, and cases, where a state is a party. And congress cannot constitutionally confer on it any other, or further original jurisdiction. This is one of the appropriate illustrations of the rule, that the affirmation of a power in particular cases, excludes it in all others. The clause itself would otherwise be wholly inoperative and nugatory. If it had been intended to leave it to the discretion of congress, to apportion the judicial power between the supreme and inferior courts, according to the will of that body, it would have been useless to have proceeded further, than to define the judicial power, and the tribunals, in which it should be vested. Affirmative words often, in their operation, imply a negative of other objects, than those affirmed; and in this case a negative, or exclusive sense, must be given to the words, or they have no operation at all. If the solicitude of the convention, respecting our peace with foreign powers, might induce a provision to be made, that the Supreme Court should have original jurisdiction in cases, which might
  1. Martin v. Hunter, 1 Wheat. R. 333, 337, 338; Osborn v. Bank of United States, 9 Wheat. R. 820, 821.
  2. Id. p. 328, 330, 336.—Upon this subject there is considerable discussion, in the case of Martin v. Hunter, (1 Wheat. R. 304, 313.)