Page:NIOSH Hazard review of Carbonless Copy Paper.pdf/121

This page has been proofread, but needs to be validated.
4 HEALTH EFFECTS

(used as color formers) have been reported to be mutagenic [Bonin et al. 1981].

Certin and Zissu I983. Certin and Zissu [1983] performed cutaneous irritation tests in rabbits. They compared extracts of 12 CCPs with 5 highly irritant reference oils, acetone (CB), or ethyl acetate or acetone (CF) extracts (4 hr of soxlet extraction of 50 g, or acetone extraction of 1 kg CB sheets in an ultrasonic tank for 1 hr). The CCP extracts were moderately or severely irritating using the Draize method (Table 4-1 3). Chemical analysis using GC/MS analysis identified the "oils" listed in Table 4-13.

Thirteen papers contained a phenolic resin in the CF layer and traces of free phenols, bis-phenol A, and phenylphenol. For all of the CF analyses, compounds similar to abietic acid were found. Certin and Zissu [1983] reported that 8 of the 12 extracts were moderately irritating (irritation index from 2.7 to 4.7), and the remaining 4 extracts were severely irritating (irritation index from 5.6 to 7.3). Histopathology results from animals exposed to moderately irritating products exhibited epidermal acanthoses alternating with superficial epidermal necrosis, which led to thin, scaly crust that was sometimes continuous over the entire extent of the lesion. The severely irritating products caused more pronounced morphological findings. These were characterized by necrosis of the epidermis and superficial dermis, with inflammatory exocytosis and homogeneous degeneration of the connective tissue of the mid-derrnis. The authors concluded that it was probably the oily constituents of the papers that produced the observed irritation of the skin and mucosa of office workers. However, they also noted that the animal test results are probably more grave than those experienced by humans, since human exposures were limited to several hundred micrograms on the fingers at the end of a day of handling. The authors

Table 4-13. Frequency of occurrence and animal irritation category for chemicals identified in 12 French CCPS
Chemical Number of times identified by GC/MS analysis Irritation category
Hydrogenated terphenyls 16 Severe
Diisopropylnaphthalenes 11 Severe
Phenylxylylethanes[1] 10 Moderate to severe
Alkylbenzenes 6 Severe
Methybutyl naphthalenes 1 Not tested
Benzylxylenes 1 Not tested
Chlorinated pacaffins 1 Not tested
Chlorinated biphenyls 1[2] Not tested
Dibutylphthalate 1 Not tested
Kerosene [3] Severe

Source: Certin and Zissu [l983].

  1. This constituent was noted to have a very pungent odor.
  2. 1972
  3. Not enumerated.
100
Carbonless Copy Paper