Thus in the Aillavagga (VI, 13, i) we find the passage—
'At that time the Blessed One proclaimed the Vinaya in many a way to the Bhikkhus, exalted the Vinaya, exalted the learning of the Vinaya, exalted again and again the venerable Upclli. Then thought the Bhikkhus, "The Blessed One hath proclaimed the Vinaya in many a way, hath exalted the Vinaya, hath exalted the learning of the Vinaya, hath exalted again and again the venerable Upclli. Come now let us learn the Vinaya from the venerable Upclli." And so many Bhikkhus, old and middle-aged and young, learnt the Vinaya from the venerable Upili.'
And again in a Sutta of the Afiguttara NikAya 1 , where those Bhikkhus are enumerated who, in any particular respect, are the first and foremost in the Brotherhood, Upclli is mentioned as the first among the custodians of the Vinaya (the Vinaya-dhard). And further, as is well known, it is Upclli who, according to the tradition, plays, at the First Council, the same part of propounder with regard to the Vinaya Texts which Ananda does with regard to the Dhamma Texts. There may well be some truth in this very ancient tradition that Upclli was specially conversant with the Rules of the Order; but it would be hazardous on that account to ascribe to Upclli a share, not only in the handing down of existing Rules, but in the composition of the Pcitimokkha itself 3 .
As regards the order in which the various offences are arranged in the Patimokkha, the principal division corresponds to the division of the Order into Brethren and Sisters: there is a Bhikkhu-pcltimokkha and a Bhikkhuni-pcltimokkha. In each of these two chief divisions the offences are divided into various classes, beginning with the heaviest -— with those, that is, that result in the exclu-
Phayre MS., vol. i. fol. kau.
In the Ceylon Chroniclers (Dipavaiwsa, Bhawavaras 4 and 5) Upali even becomes the first in a series ofVinayapamokkha, or 4 Chiefs of the Vinaya ;' but no such office is known to the older tradition; and had it existed it would certainly have been mentioned in connection with the dispute about the so-called Ten Points of the Vinaya at the Council of Vesali.
- Kullavagga XII.