It is difficult to see how the fallacy of this argument could have been detected by any one not familiar with the fundamental physiological law that the nature of a sensation is in no wise determined by the character of the agent producing it, but only by the character of the nerves acted upon; but, as already intimated, this law belongs to a later epoch than the one we are considering. Herschel thus finally concluded that light and radiant heat were of essentially different natures, and upon this supposition he explained all of the phenomena which his numerous experiments had shown him. So complete and satisfactory did this work appear to the scientific world, that for a long time the question was looked upon as closed, and not until thirty-five years later was there any dissent. Then the Italian physicist, Melloni, with instrumental means a thousand times more delicate than that of Herschel, and with a far larger store of cognate phenomena, collected during the generation which had elapsed, to serve as a guide, discovered the true law. This, as we have seen, was at first adopted
Page:Sir William Herschel, his life and works (1881).djvu/208
This page has been validated.
186
Life and Works
![](http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/f/f6/Sir_William_Herschel%2C_his_life_and_works_%281881%29.djvu/page208-1024px-Sir_William_Herschel%2C_his_life_and_works_%281881%29.djvu.jpg)