Page:The Crimes of the Stalin Era (Khrushchev, tr. Nicolaevsky).djvu/26

This page has been proofread, but needs to be validated.

bers actually questioned the rightness of the established course regarding mass repressions under the pretext of combating "two-facedness."

Comrade Postyshev[1] most ably expressed these doubts. He said:

"I have philosophized that the severe years of fighting have passed. Party members who have lost their backbones have broken down or have joined the camp of the enemy; healthy elements have fought for the party. These were the years of industrialization and collectivization. I never thought it possible that after this severe era had passed Karpov and people like him would find themselves in the camp of the enemy. (Karpov was a worker in the Ukrainian Central Committee whom Postyshev knew well.) And now, according to the testimony, it appears that Karpov was recruited in 1934 by the Trotskyites. I personally do not believe that in 1934 an honest party member who had trod the long road of unrelenting fight against enemies for the party and for socialism would now be in the camp of the enemies. I do not believe it. . . . I cannot imagine how it would be possible to travel with the party during the difficult years and then, in 1934, join the Trotskyites. It is an odd thing. . . ." (Movement in the hall.)

Using Stalin's formulation, namely, that the closer we are to socialism the more enemies we will have, and using the resolution of the February-March Central Committee plenum passed on the basis of Yezhov's report, the provocateurs who had infiltrated the state-security organs together with conscienceless careerists began to protect with the party name the mass terror against party cadres, cadres of the Soviet state and the ordinary Soviet citizens. It should suffice to say that the number of arrests based on charges of counterrevolutionary crimes had grown ten times between 1936 and 1937.

It is known that brutal willfulness was practiced against leading party workers. The party statue, approved at the 17th Party Congress, was based on Leninist principles expressed at the 10th Party Congress. It stated that, in order to apply an extreme method such as exclusion from the party against a Central Committee member, against a Central Committee candidate and against a member of the Party Control Commission, "it is necessary to call a Central Committee plenum and to invite to the plenum all Central Committee candidate members and all members of the Party Control Commission"; only if two-thirds of the members of such a general assembly of re-


  1. Pavel P. Postyshev (1888–1938), a worker from Ivanovo-Voznesensk and a Bolshevik since 1904, became a secretary of the Central Committee in 1930 and Secretary of the Ukrainian Communist party in February 1933. A backer of Stalin in earlier years, he supported Stalin's opponents in the fall of 1932 on the question of executing Communist oppositionists; after that, Stalin removed him from the central Party apparatus and sent him to the Ukraine. In 1936–37, Postyshev, it is now apparent, was among those who tried to oppose the Yezhovshchina. For this lie was sent in March 1937 to Kuibyshev province as Party Secretary. In 1938 he was arrested and shot.
S26