Page:Time and Tide by Weare and Tyne.djvu/21

This page has been proofread, but needs to be validated.
7

LETTER II.

Co-operation, as hitherto understood, is perhaps not expedient.

February 4, 1867.

4.LIMITING the inquiry, then, for the present as proposed in the close of my last letter, to the form of co-operation which is now upon its trial in practice, I would beg of you to observe that the points at issue, in the comparison of this system with that of mastership, are by no means hitherto frankly stated; still less can they as yet be fairly brought to test. For all mastership is not alike in principle; there are just and unjust masterships; and while, on the one hand, there can be no question but that co-operation is better than unjust and tyrannous mastership, there is very great room for doubt whether it be better than a just and benignant mastership.

5. At present you—every one of you—speak, and act, as if there were only one