Page:Metaphysics by Aristotle Ross 1908 (deannotated).djvu/104

This page needs to be proofread.

are called causes as being able to act, others as acting, e.g. the cause of the house's being built is the builder, or the builder when building. — The same variety of language will be found with regard to the effects of causes, e.g. a thing may be called the cause of this statue or of a statue or in general of an image, and of this bronze[1] or of bronze or of matter in general; and similarly in the case of accidental effects. Again, both accidental and proper causes may be spoken of in combination, e.g. we may say not 'Polyclitus' nor 'the sculptor', but 'Polyclitus the sculptor'.

Yet all these are but six in number, while each is spoken of in two ways; for (1) they are causes either as the individual, or as the class that includes the individual,[2] or as the accidental, or as the class that includes the accidental, and these either as combined,[3] or as taken simply; and (2) all may be taken as acting or as having a capacity. But they differ inasmuch as the acting causes and the individuals exist, or do not exist, simultaneously with the things of which they are causes, e.g. this particular man who is curing, with this particular man who is recovering health, and this particular builder with this particular thing that is being built; but the potential causes are not always in this case; for the house does not perish at the same time as the builder.[4]


Chapter 3

'Element' means the primary component immanent in a thing, and indivisible in kind into other kinds, e.g. the elements of speech are the parts of which speech consists and into which it is ultimately divided, while they are no longer divided into other forms of speech different in kind from them. If they are divided, their parts are of the same kind, as a part of water is water (while a part of the syllable is not a syllable). Similarly those who speak of the elements of bodies mean the things into which bodies are ultimately

  1. For this way of speaking cf. Phys. II. 194a 33.
  2. 1014a 17 for αὐτοῦ read τοῦ καθ' ἕκαστον.
  3. Sc. the particular proper cause with the particular accidental, or the general proper with the general accidental.
  4. With this chapter cf. Phys. II. 3.