v] Causal conditions 143 one is trying to win a real nirvaQa 1. It is this false egoism that is to be considered as avidya. "hen considered deeply it is found that there is not even the slightest trace of any positive existence. Thus it is seen that if there were no ignorance (avidyii), there would have been no conformations (sa1!lskiiras), and if there were no conformations there would have been no consciousness, and so on; but it cannot be said of the ignorance "I am generating the sarpskaras," and it can be said of the sarpskaras "we are being produced by the avidya." But there being avidya, there come the sarpskaras and so on with other categories too. This character of the pratttyasamutpada is known as the coming of the consequent depending on an antecedent reason (hetitpanibandha). I t can be viewed from another aspect, namely that of depend- ence on conglomeration or combination <pratyayopaniba11dha). It is by the combination (samaviiya) of the four elements, space (iikiisa) and consciousness (vijfzii1za) that a man is made. It is due to earth (P.rthivl) that the body becomes solid, it is due to water that there is fat in the body, it is due to fire that there is digestion, it is due to wind that there is respiration; it is due to akasa that there is porosity, and it is due to vijfiana that there is mind-consciousness. It is by their mutual combination that we find a man as he is. But none of these elements think that they have done any of the functions that are considered to be allotted to them. None of these are real substances or beings or souls. I t is by ignorance that these are thought of as existents and attachment is generated for them. Through ignorance thus come the sarpskaras, consisting of attachment, antipathy and thought- lessness (raga, dvea, moha); from these proceed the vijfiana and the four skandhas. These with the four elements bring about name and form (llamaritpa), from these proceed the senses (acJiiyatana), from the coming together of those three comes contact (sparsa); from that feelings, from that comes desire (trJ!ii) and so on. These flow on like the stream of a river, but there is no essence or truth behind them all or as the ground of them a1l 2 . The phenomena therefore cannot be said to be either existent or non-existent, and no truth can be affirmed of either eternalism (Siisvataviida) or nihilism (ucchedaviida), and it is for this reason 1 See .LJIiidhyamikavrtti (B.T.S.), pp. 101-108.
Ibid. pp. 209-2 I r, quoted from Siilistambhasiitra. Vacaspatimisra also quotes
this passage in his Bldimati on Sankara's Brallma-..iitra.
