The poetical incident of most importance in Tickell's life was his publication of the first book of the Iliad, as translated by himself, an apparent opposition to Pope's Homer, of which the first part made its entrance into the world at the same time.
Addison declared that the rival versions were both good; but that Tickell's was the best that was ever made; and with Addison the wits, his adherents and followers, were certain to concur. Pope does not appear to have been much dismayed; "for," says he, "I have the town, that is the mob on my side." But he remarks, "that it is common for the smaller party to make up in diligence what they want in numbers; he appeals to the people as his proper judges; and if they are not inclined to condemn him, he is in little care about the high-flyers at Button's."
Pope did not long think Addison an impartial judge; for he considered him, as the writer of Tickell's version. The reasons for his suspicion I will literally transcribe from Mr. Spence's Collection.
"There had been a coldness (said Mr. Pope) between Mr. Addison and me for some time;
