November 1904 edit
- Number 1
- (p.2): Illustration by Maxfield Parrish for The Rawhide
- (p.3): Grover Cleveland - Parker
- (p.8): Henry Cabot Lodge - Roosevelt
- (p.11): Grace S. Richmond - Kilbreth of Ballyraggan
- (p.21): Stewart Edward White - The Rawhide
- (p.30): A. W. Rolker - The Black Roan of "265"
- (p.40): Ray Stannard Baker - Parker and Roosevelt on Labor
- (p.53): Myra Kelly - A Passport to Paradise
- (p.63): - The Thaw at Slisco's
- (p.70): Booth Tarkington - The Need of Money
- (p.80): Robert Loveman - Yesterday Ran Roses
- (p.81): James Hopper - The Passing of the Vet
- (p.90): M. H. Carter - The Parent
- (p.101): W. Henry Sheak - Out of the Jaws of Deathj
- (p.107): On the Making of McClure's Magazine
December 1904 edit
- Number 2
- (p.112): Illustration by Maxfield Parrish for The Rawhide
- (p.113): James Hopper - A Jumble in Divinities
- (p.123): O. Henry - The Ransom of Mack
- (p.126): Ray Stannard Baker - The Rise of the Tailors
- (p.140): Marion Hill - His Journey to the Gates
- (p.148): George Madden Martin - God Rest You, Merry Christians
- (p.154): Rex E. Beach - The Test
- (p.162): Erratum to October issue
- (p.163): S. S. McClure - The Increase of Lawlessness in the United States
- (p.172): Stewart Edward White - The Rawhide, Continued
- (p.178): Herman Knickerbocker Viele - The Money Meter
- (p.188): Samuel Hopkins Adams, editor - Notes from a Trainer's Book
- (p.198): Florence Wilkinson - The Dream-Child
- (p.199): John La Farge - One Hundred Masterpieces of Painting, Allegories, Part One
- (p.206): Janet Remington - The Way Wonderful
- (p.216): George W. Alger - Miss Tarbell's History of the Standard Oil Company
- (p.224): Richard Burton - Ballade of the Brave
- NOTE: To be established whether this is the same person as Richard Francis Burton
January 1905 edit
- Number 3
- (p.224): Illustration by Maxfield Parrish for The Rawhide
- (p.225): Henry Wallace Phillips - A Touch of Nature
- (p.234): Samuel Hopkins Adams - Tuberculosis: The Real Race Suicide
- (p.250): Saumas MacManus - The Steed of Bells
- (p.258): Frederic Irland - The Reporter Who Became President
- (p.266): Grace S. Richmond - Billy's Orgy
- (p.274): N. M. W. Woodrow - Old Man Johnson's Successor
- (p.284): Stewart Edward White - The Rawhide, Continued
- (p.289): John Dwight - For Love of Country
- (p.292): C. E. Williams - A Glimpse of Beavers at Work
- (p.298): A. E. Housman - Song|Song (Housman)|Song
- (p.299): Ray Stannard Baker - What Is a Lynching?, Part I
- (p.314): Mark Lee Luther - The Schism at St. Hilda's
- (p.320): Charles Fleming Embree - The Liberty of Florentino
- (p.329): Willa Cather - The Sculptor's Funeral|The Sculptor's Funeral (Cather)|The Sculptor's Funeral
- (p.336): Florence Wilkinson - The Child That Once You Were
February 1905 edit
- Number 4
- (facing p.337): Illustration for The Old Major
- (p.337): Lincoln Steffens - Rhode Island: A State for Sale
- (p.354): Florence Tinsley Cox - The Old Major
- (p.359): Samuel Hopkins Adams - A Man and a Brother
- (p.366): Harvey J. O'Higgins - A Personally Conducted Revolt
- (p.374): Edwin Lefevre - The Golden Flood, Part I
- (p.390): Eugene Wood - The Old Red School-House
- (p.401): John La Farge - One Hundred Masterpieces of Painting, Allegories, Part Two
- (p.407): John Vance Cheney - Thus Runs the World Away
- (p.408): Booth Tarkington - Mrs. Protheroe
- (p.422): Ray Stannard Baker - What Is a Lynching?, Part II
- (p.430): Florence Wilkinson - Purple Crocuses in the Val Bregaglia
- (p.431): A. W. Rolker - Wild Animal Trapping
- (p.442): Gelett Burgess - Failure
- (p.443): Peter S. Grosscup - How to Save the Corporation
March 1905 edit
- Number 5
- (p.450): Illustration for Service
- (p.451): Ray Stannard Baker - The Subway "Deal"
- (p.469): William Butler Yeats - Red Hanrahan's Vision
- (p.472): Anna H. Branch - Service
- (p.473): Jeannette Cooper - A Wasted Rehearsal
- (p.482): Samuel Hopkins Adams - Modern Surgery
- (p.493): Fredericj E. Scotford - Three Toes
- (p.502): Edwin Lefevre - The Golden Flood, Part II
- (p.512): A. E. Housman - I Shall Have Lived
- (p.513): Marion Hill - A Happy Lapse from Paradise
- (p.522): John McAuley Palmer - The Man in the Pigeonhole
- (p.529): John La Farge - One Hundred Masterpieces of Painting, The primitives—The Flemish
- (p.538): Mary Stewart Cutting - In the Family
- (p.543): James Hopper - The Maestro of Balangilang
- (p.554): Henry A. Castle - Careless, Ignorant, and Defiant Postmasters
April 1905 edit
- Number 6
- (p.562): Burton J. Hendrick - The Astor Fortune
- (p.578): A. E. Housman - Song|Song (Housman)|Song
- (p.579): Mary Stewart Cutting - In Regard to Josephine
- (p.587): Florence Tinsley Cox - A Social Event
- (p.592): Edwin Lefevre - The Golden Flood, Part III
- (p.608): Perceval Gibbon - What Ails Russia
- (p.616): George Edward Woodberry - GFreat Masters of Literature
- (p.624): Wilfred T. Grenfell - Leaves from the Log of the "Lend-a-Hand"
- (p.633): Ceylon E. Hollingsworth - A Corner-Stone Calf
- (p.639): Horatio Winslow - Here's the End of Dreamland
- (p.640): Richard Washburn Child - Speedaway
- (p.649): Lincoln Steffens - New Jersey: A Traitor State
- (p.665): Larrey Bowman - The Faithful Brady